5-1-2 "Player control foul after a goal?"

[tref]

A1 shoots the floater in the lane...swish
Upon returning to the floor A1 crashes into B1... p/c send it up north!

[SNIPERBBB]

Originally Posted by tref

A1 shoots the floater in the lane...swish
Upon returning to the floor A1 crashes into B1... p/c send it up north!

That would be a pushing foul on A1. Basket counts.

[tref]

Originally Posted by SNIPERBBB

That would be a pushing foul on A1. Basket counts.

Yup, in NCAA-M

[SNIPERBBB]

Originally Posted by tref

Yup, in NCAA-M

Nfhs too once the shooter lands he is just another player on the court.

[tref]

Originally Posted by Freddy

Re. 5-1-2, "If a player-control foul occurs before or after a goal, the goal is canceled."

In what situation could a player-control foul occur after a goal?

Hmmmm did I misread the question or did you

[BktBallRef]

Originally Posted by tref

Hmmmm did I misread the question or did you

You did.

Once an airborne shooter returns to the floor, it is no longer a player control foul when he crashes into a defender.

[tref]

Originally Posted by BktBallRef

You did.

Once an airborne shooter returns to the floor, it is no longer a player control foul when he crashes into a defender.

Really??

Forget Rosetta Stone bring that Hooked on Phonics back!!

Reading is FUNdamental

[bob jenkins]

Originally Posted by SNIPERBBB

That would be a pushing foul on A1. Basket counts.

Originally Posted by tref

Yup, in NCAA-M

Actually, it would be ignored in all codes, unless it was intentional (aka Flagrant 1) or flagrant (2). And, then, it would be a T.

Now, if tref said, "...BEFORE returning to the floor ..." we'd have a PC foul in FED and NCAAW and a common foul in NCAAM

[tref]

Originally Posted by bob jenkins

Actually, it would be ignored in all codes, unless it was intentional (aka Flagrant 1) or flagrant (2). And, then, it would be a T.

Now, if tref said, "...BEFORE returning to the floor ..." we'd have a PC foul in FED and NCAAW and a common foul in NCAAM

Before/Upon... endline/baseline... player control/offense

[Smitty]

Originally Posted by tref

Before/Upon

These are not the same.

[tref]

Okay, if a shooter scores on a try & crashes into the defender BEFORE returning to the playing surface then we dont count the basket because of a p/c foul in HS.

Around here you can really tell when people dont have a game to work.

Time for Facebook...

[constable]

Originally Posted by bob jenkins

Actually, it would be ignored in all codes, unless it was intentional (aka Flagrant 1) or flagrant (2). And, then, it would be a T.

Now, if tref said, "...BEFORE returning to the floor ..." we'd have a PC foul in FED and NCAAW and a common foul in NCAAM and FIBA

Fixed it for ya!

[Raymond]

Originally Posted by tref

A1 shoots the floater in the lane...swish
Upon returning to the floor A1 crashes into B1... p/c send it up north!

I knew what you meant....so did everyone else. They should have just pointed out that your exact wording was wrong.

[bob jenkins]

Originally Posted by BadNewsRef

I knew what you meant....so did everyone else. They should have just pointed out that your exact wording was wrong.

Actually, I have met officials who thought that the rule was (more or less) as he worded it -- that if A1 contacted B1 upon (meaning "immediately after") returning to the floor, it was a PC foul. Different officials have (incorrectly) said the "PC foul period" lasts until both feet are on the floor, or through "continuous motion", or until A1 came to a stop or turned the other direction, ...