Can You Do What's Right ??

[MN 3 Sport Ref]

Originally posted by Jeff the Ref
Are you saying that we have no try!

B was the last to tip the ball. Their 'tap" or a better word de is not a try, does the ball not become dead immediately when the horn sounds.

However I bet you could make a pretty good case that A touched the ball near the same time and then B deflected it therefore the ball is not dead because B's touch is part of A's try. Definately either way it would take a lot of fortitude to make the call. i would definately have to be there in that sitch to decide my course of action.