Travel??? while OOB

[canuckrefguy]

Originally posted by Buckley11
I think I have read this whole thread and I must admit I am having a brain cramp........WHAT IS THE PROPER SIGNAL FOR THIS VIOLATION......

Just hoping to get something constructive from this thread.....

Another poster described it as sweeping motion of the arm, along the line in question.

I can't believe the nit-picking here, though.

NCAA Division I and even NBA refs use all kinds of signals, many of them not mentioned in any mechanics book. The top level refs are there because they generally make great calls, have great game management, and experience.

I doubt VERY MUCH if anyone, including the evaluator, mentioned the "improper signal" other than in passing. I do not doubt, however, that he was complimented for making the right call under such frenetic conditions.

While the points expressed are valid to a certain degree, I think it's incredibly silly to be picking apart MINOR details of an official's work.

This board should not be used in this way.