The Official Forum

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)
-   Basketball (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/)
-   -   2011 NCAA Tournament Officials (Master Thread) (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/64992-2011-ncaa-tournament-officials-master-thread.html)

Camron Rust Thu Mar 31, 2011 04:11am

Quote:

Originally Posted by canuckrefguy (Post 745378)
As for all the Burr-bashing. In the infamous Rutgers game - it was neither Burr nor Tim Higgins that were the primary official in what I think are the biggest f-ups in the dying minutes of that game: (1) the obvious rebounding foul that was passed on (C on the play was up above the 3pt line when the foul occurred off a missed FT), but positioned way too high IMO), and another foul on the hail mary pass at the end where the Rutgers guy is basically knocked down. Earl Walton was the closest official on both those plays - but Higgins and Burr got all the vitriol. Not defending any of them - but Walton kind of got off scott-free in the court of public opinion IMO.

On the FT rebound, Higgins was the lead and was standing about 4' INBOUNDS, a position several feet from where he should have been and one that took away any chance he had of helping across the lane with contact. As you said, the C/Walton was also way too high but still should have been able to see it from where he was. Either one could have got that one. There was no reason for Higgins to be that far inbounds. It was as if he was anticipating the make or the rebound to go the other way and wanted to get a head start since he's not so fast. If he has to do that to keep up, maybe its time to retire.

I didn't think the hail mary was a foul. That ball was up for grabs and both players with basically straight up for the ball. Just because one falls down doesn't mean the other one fouled him.

Burr should have had line coverage on the OOB with Higgins providing secondary coverage. Walton, being directly across the court, wouldn't have had any way to reliably tell if the player was inbounds or not.

So, yes, a foul was missed. Fouls are missed. The biggest gaff in that game was the player running OOB with the ball with no whistle....that one falls only on Burr & Higgins. Walton may have been able to save the day but it would have been difficult to see from his spot (which was a correct location form him to be).

JRutledge Thu Mar 31, 2011 09:04am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Camron Rust (Post 745423)
I didn't think the hail mary was a foul. That ball was up for grabs and both players with basically straight up for the ball. Just because one falls down doesn't mean the other one fouled him.

Burr should have had line coverage on the OOB with Higgins providing secondary coverage. Walton, being directly across the court, wouldn't have had any way to reliably tell if the player was inbounds or not.

So, yes, a foul was missed. Fouls are missed. The biggest gaff in that game was the player running OOB with the ball with no whistle....that one falls only on Burr & Higgins. Walton may have been able to save the day but it would have been difficult to see from his spot (which was a correct location form him to be).

I totally agree.

I will add that to me the rebounding situation was not necessarily a foul either. It looked to me like players fell down, not that anyone was necessarily pushed. And that is a judgment call and we make many of those people will disagree with from time to time.

Peace

kellybluemen Sun Apr 03, 2011 05:21pm

Looks like it will be

John Cahill
Vern Harris
Doug Showes

In the Finals tomorrow, good crew, should be a great game!

GoodwillRef Mon Apr 04, 2011 10:57am

Quote:

Originally Posted by kellybluemen (Post 746503)
Looks like it will be

John Cahill
Vern Harris
Doug Showes

In the Finals tomorrow, good crew, should be a great game!

Cahill working back to back title games...not to shabby!

canuckrefguy Mon Apr 04, 2011 06:36pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by BadNewsRef (Post 745386)
Burr should have positioned himself to be able to officiate the hail mary. Walton was where he was supposed be on the throw-in.

http://i93.photobucket.com/albums/l5...ntitled-11.jpg

Who's got the first look on this play? Walton at the centre position. Burr could have been a bit closer on the play - but he's behind the last two players, pretty much where he should be. He could have been "wider" - but still probably would have been straightlined. In either case, Walton still would have had the better angle.

If you watch the replays, the Rutger's player clearly catches the ball outright, and then the St. John's player hacks/grabs him across the inside of his forearms, which causes him to lose the ball and fall backwards onto the floor. Foul.

If the catch had been "iffy" or the ball "up for grabs", I agree, a no-call is the way to go. But the pass was bang-on, and the Rutger's player timed his jump well enough to secure control of the pass. He deserves protection from excessive contact that takes away the play he just made.

I can live with the no-call on the rebound, given all the chaos off the missed FT. But that play on the pass should have been called.

Agree wholeheartedly that falling asleep on the OOB with 1.7 left was an egregious screw-up by Burr/Higgins. My original point was that it was the cherry on top of an extremely bad last minute or so.

Nevadaref Mon Apr 04, 2011 07:11pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by GoodwillRef (Post 746703)
Cahill working back to back title games...not to shabby!

Actually, it's 3 out of the last 4. Not only did he work last year's game, but also the 2008 final in San Antonio.

Also, in 2009 he worked one of the semis.

2007 was the last time that he did not work one of the games at the Final Four.

Raymond Mon Apr 04, 2011 07:14pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by canuckrefguy (Post 746825)
http://i93.photobucket.com/albums/l5...ntitled-11.jpg

Who's got the first look on this play? Walton at the centre position. Burr could have been a bit closer on the play - but he's behind the last two players, pretty much where he should be. He could have been "wider" - but still probably would have been straightlined. In either case, Walton still would have had the better angle.

...

There is absolutely no reason for Burr to be behind the last 2 players on this play. He could have officiated those 2 players from the free throw line extended. It would have given the crew inside and outside coverage of the attempted catch.

In the unlikely scenario that Rutgers would have attempted to throw a pass 90' to the deepest player Walton is more than fast enough to have made his way down the court to help and Burr would have only had to move 12-13' once he saw where the pass was going.

Nevadaref Mon Apr 04, 2011 08:14pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by BadNewsRef (Post 746853)
... and Burr would have only had to move 12-13' once he saw where the pass was going.

But he is not capable of moving that distance in that amount of time. :eek:

oceagoagece Wed Feb 22, 2012 01:15am

Hello
 
:)

oceagoagece Wed Feb 29, 2012 03:49pm

Hello
 
<1234567890><1234567890>

oceagoagece Mon Mar 26, 2012 06:03pm

Hello
 
** Спустя час, изрядно насытившись двойной порцией и договорившись с генералом Ростовым об охране своего турбоглиссера до прибытия подразделения техников, Красс был готов к отлету на Землю. Генерал имел в своем распоряжении добрую сотню ремонтников высшего класса и огромное количество дройдов того же назначения, но не стал задавать вопросов, зачем нужно дожидаться какую-то специальную команду, а просто выставил охранение вокруг блока, в котором находился разбитый вдребезги турбоглиссер "Змея". Вместо него Ростов снабдил капитана "Невидимых" штурмовым шаттлом типа "Керн" с двумя пилотами на борту. Кроме того, до Сатурна его должны были сопровождать два штурмовика типа "Ястреб".
<a href=http://devushki-moskvy.ru/studentki-prostitutki-moskvi.html>проститутки студентки</a>
** Макс протиснулся в пробоину, предварительно убедившись по сканеру, что его там никто не ждет. За воротами начинался огромный тоннель, в который при желании свободно мог влететь истребитель. Луч портативного прожектора Макса скользнул по настенным кабелям и утонул во мраке.
проститутки студенточки
** _ Не думаю, _ ответила Астра, помедлив, _ скорее эта модель здесь инородная.
маши
** Лев недовольно зарычал, ему хотелось поиграть.
<a href=http://devushki-moskvy.ru/prostitutki-moskvi-mashki.html>maski v moskve</a>
** — Стой не месте, Свен, — Рафи предупредительно поднял руку.

JetMetFan Wed Mar 28, 2012 05:59am

Quote:

Originally Posted by BadNewsRef (Post 746853)
There is absolutely no reason for Burr to be behind the last 2 players on this play. He could have officiated those 2 players from the free throw line extended. It would have given the crew inside and outside coverage of the attempted catch.

In the unlikely scenario that Rutgers would have attempted to throw a pass 90' to the deepest player Walton is more than fast enough to have made his way down the court to help and Burr would have only had to move 12-13' once he saw where the pass was going.

Wow. I haven't seen these plays since a few days after it happened. Ahh, the anger at the time :)

In terms of Higgins' he was actually standing on the court while the FTs were being shot before the inbounds pass. All he did was back up to the sideline while staying 4-5 feet from the endline.

Burr broke the cardinal rule I was taught early on: there shouldn't be 94 feet (or 84 feet in H.S.) between me and the ball when I'm the L and the ball is being inbounded in the backcourt. If he's at the FT line extended he can see anything he needs to. It's not as though the Rutgers players would've been able to catch the pass and dribble unimpeded to the basket.

As for Walton, I actually thought he could've seen the player run out OOB with the ball since he's supposed to be responsible for the ball from arc to arc in that situation. At the very least at the time I felt he should've called a travel before (or as) the SJU player was going OOB which could've solved a lot.

oceagoagece Wed Mar 28, 2012 08:01am

Hello
 
com/at-home-whitening/ - SimilarHomemade teeth whitener can give you a Hollywood smile without the Hollywood price and these homemade teeth whitener recipes call for ingredients you...
<a href=http://teeth-whitening-tricks.com/tanning-bed-teeth-whitening/everwhite-teeth-whitening/>led teeth whitening reviews</a> shtml - SimilarTop 7 Teeth Whiteners - Reviews of the most effective teeth whitening products on the Internet.
organic teeth whitening
Different people respond differently to...

oceagoagece Fri Mar 30, 2012 08:16am

Hello
 
Его идеал пока заключался в том, чтобы подергать за хвост попугая.
<a href=http://nomera-shlyuh-moskvy.ru/map.html>азиатские проститутки в москве</a> Или там ее кабинет?
азиатские проститутки Она с некоторым трудом поднялась на второй этаж красивого нового до ма, задержалась на мгновение на площадке, чтобы отдышаться, и вошла к Кольберу, который сам распахнул перед ней двери. <a href=http://elitniyeskortmoskva.ru/map.html>prostitutku yugo zapadnaya</a> А потом на простыне сюда принесли бросили.
путаны вднх У него нервы крепкие.

Pumpy25 Fri Mar 30, 2012 10:30am

Just a question...how is Roger ayers in the final four? Thismis thensame guymwho missed the call of 6 players on the floor in the western KY game. What is the process in selecting officials...ismthere no reprimand for making an epic screw up

Camron Rust Fri Mar 30, 2012 04:11pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pumpy25 (Post 834911)
Just a question...how is Roger ayers in the final four? Thismis thensame guymwho missed the call of 6 players on the floor in the western KY game. What is the process in selecting officials...ismthere no reprimand for making an epic screw up

You're making a lot of assumptions here.

Adam Fri Mar 30, 2012 05:10pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pumpy25 (Post 834911)
Just a question...how is Roger ayers in the final four? Thismis thensame guymwho missed the call of 6 players on the floor in the western KY game. What is the process in selecting officials...ismthere no reprimand for making an epic screw up

For a mistake in December?

And my 6 year old has better writing skills than this.

Yeah, I said it.

tomegun Fri Mar 30, 2012 09:49pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Snaqwells (Post 834963)
For a mistake in December?

And my 6 year old has better writing skills than this.

Yeah, I said it.

It makes it so hard to read. Annoying.

Adam Sat Mar 31, 2012 12:27am

Quote:

Originally Posted by tomegun (Post 835025)
It makes it so hard to read. Annoying.

Looks like he was typing on his phone from study hall.

Raymond Sun Apr 01, 2012 10:00am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pumpy25 (Post 834911)
Just a question...how is Roger ayers in the final four? Thismis thensame guymwho missed the call of 6 players on the floor in the western KY game. What is the process in selecting officials...ismthere no reprimand for making an epic screw up

I heard through reliable sources that the entire crew lost one Sun Belt game.

grunewar Mon Apr 02, 2012 06:41pm

Not too late to go.......
 
Fans can buy tix to championship game for as little as $30

icallfouls Mon Apr 02, 2012 07:17pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pumpy25 (Post 834911)
Just a question...how is Roger ayers in the final four? Thismis thensame guymwho missed the call of 6 players on the floor in the western KY game. What is the process in selecting officials...ismthere no reprimand for making an epic screw up

Just wondering what you think would have been an appropriate penalty?

Camron Rust Mon Apr 02, 2012 07:43pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by icallfouls (Post 835479)
Just wondering what you think would have been an appropriate penalty?

His standard would ultimately suspend all officials and the players would be left playing the game calling their own fouls. :p

stiffler3492 Mon Apr 02, 2012 08:29pm

I missed the beginning of the game...who are the final three?

canuckrefguy Mon Apr 02, 2012 09:28pm

Verne Harris
Mark Whitehead
Mike Stuart

BktBallRef Mon Apr 02, 2012 09:44pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pumpy25 (Post 834911)
Just a question...how is Roger ayers in the final four? Thismis thensame guymwho missed the call of 6 players on the floor in the western KY game. What is the process in selecting officials...ismthere no reprimand for making an epic screw up

"...epic screwup...? I would venture to say that every official who has ever officiated a game has had a situation where they had 6 players on the floor. If you were an official, it would happen to you as well.

But to answer your question, the crew did lose a Sun Belt game. The NCAA doesn't have any involvment in that decision. One mistake does not a season or career destroy.

Yeah, yeah, I know you think he should have been burned at the stake. Sorry.

michref Tue Apr 03, 2012 01:11am

Pumpy25......Or....perhaps....Mr Adams saw more games worked by Ayers throughout the season....the ACC tournament....and the NCAA tournament leading up to the Final Four and felt...."Roger has really recovered from that error and has taken his season to another level and is refereeing at even a higher level then before.." hence Mr Adams and the others involved rewarding him with a Final Four assignment.

Just a thought to ponder...

oceagoagece Tue Apr 03, 2012 02:29am

Hello
 
В последние месяцы Президент даже разучился говорить самостоятельно, предпочитая читать по бумажке заранее написанный текст. <a href=http://prostitutkimoskvymolodye.ru/>молодые шлюхи</a> Нужно отдать им должное, делали они это явно с удовольствием. молодые шлюхи Я ухватился двумя руками за дверь ванной.

oceagoagece Tue Apr 03, 2012 07:29pm

Hello
 
SimilarLearn the best way to lose weight fast.
<a href=http://bumagire.hostweb4u.info/>here</a> This protocol is designed to...

oceagoagece Wed Apr 11, 2012 11:37pm

Hello
 
- SimilarWeight loss 4 Idiots Diet regime - Is Weight Reduction Extremely hard Without... <a href=http://viviviagagagrara.tk/?c=result&query=viagra online without prescription>viagra online canadian pharmacy</a>
Healthy Weight Loss Program.
viagra samples There are times when you...
<a href=http://yocuqehi.freewebspace.ws/>Guestbook dieters</a> Detailed Sensa System review plus other diet reviews.
<a href=http://hukomuq.host4freeonline.info/>on this site</a> You have the ability to save up to 72%.
Guestbook dieters SimilarWe compare diet pills such as Phentermine, Xenical, Bontril and Meridia.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:14pm.



Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.3.0 RC1