What are "we" telling coaches?

[zm1283]

Originally Posted by SAK

Watching televised basketball is a great aid to help pick up what advantage/disadvantage looks like. However, there is a difference between watching the TV and listening to the commentators. Even the best commentators have very limited knowledge of the rules. And sometimes a little knowledge is a dangerous thing, especially when those with a little knowledge try to pass themselves off as experts. Don't get me wrong, I like watching games that Dick Vitale is working but he knows very little about basketball rules. Too may are listening to what he as to say as if it comes out of the rule books. Coaches need to realize that in a high school game the officials have undergone comprehensive rules studies and have likely been to several basketball camps to improve on their craft. Stop asking for the "over the back" and the "reach" calls as these are simply not fouls. Also realize that a foul requires contact however, not all contact is a foul.

Sorry, just had to vent.

Also, where did the notion come from that when shooting a technical foul all players (non shooting) need to be behind the division line?

Unfortunately the bolded part is not true for the majority of high school officials, at least in this area, and in many others I suspect. You would be shocked at the number of rules that partners try to enforce or not enforce that are plain wrong.

So far this year I've been told that:

- Other nine players have to be behind the division line during technical foul FTs (Almost every official I know believes this to be true....even saw D1 officials enforce it this weekend).

- Only the players on the court can shoot technical foul FTs. Bench players are not eligible.

- That once the book has been checked at the 10-minute mark, it is final and scorekeeper error (Copying down the wrong number from a roster) doesn't exist and a technical must be given.

I'm sure I'll think of more.

Originally Posted by RichMSN

Who knows? I had a game Saturday with 3 technicals and a flagrant and all the players dutifully went behind the division line. Who am I to stop them?

Originally Posted by mbyron

Right, why would you stop them? They're legal back there.

Originally Posted by SAK

I had a game where a technical foul was called (I think that my partner called it as he went opposite table and I administered the free throws) and he told all the players to go behind the mid court line. He was the R on the game, not that R or U1 matters at that point, but I wasn't going to stop him from having them go behind half court. Just wondering where that idea come from.

Not only have I had partners put all the other players behind the division line, I heard a veteran partner tell a rookie official that the team whose bench is in the backcourt should not be allowed to talk to their coach near the sideline since the team with the frontcourt bench can't cross the division line to talk to their coach.