The Official Forum

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)
-   Basketball (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/)
-   -   Designated starters (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/60744-designated-starters.html)

Rich Wed Jan 19, 2011 10:01am

Designated starters
 
GV last night. I went over to the table with about 11 minutes left. (Captains at 12 minutes here and to the table right afterwards. May have been 11:15 or so on the clock when I walked over.) Noticed the visiting scorer was copying the official book. No biggy, I have other things to do.

So I chatted with the timer (the BV coach and a fine baseball umpire), took a bunch of air out of the basketball (it bounced up to my neck when I dropped it), and checked the possession arrows, etc. I also found out that a good sportsmanship report I sent after a previous game was read and appreciated by all -- I didn't even know it had been published.

With about 7 minutes on the clock, I finally got the official book and immediately noticed that the starters weren't marked. Actually, there were numbers next to the players and I thought that the ones marked "1" were the starters, so I asked the timer (as a coach, I figured he'd set me straight). He immediately called over the GV coach and brusquely told him that he needed to designate his starters. Whoops. The coach went down the list and picked five players as if he really didn't know who he was starting. Maybe he was just looking for the names in the book.

In the meantime, I signed the other book (the visiting scorer was nowhere to be found) and I had the timer enter the scorers in that book as well. I passed on assessing the technical foul, mainly because I would've had that fixed at 11 minutes had the book not been in the hands of the visiting scorer.

So, question for the group: Would it be better at 11 minutes to say to the visiting scorer -- "I need the official book for a minute and I'll give it right back to you" or simply do what I did? This little voice inside my head says I should've taken the book at 11 minutes just in case the visiting coach/scorer had made a big deal about this. As it was, we had no problems and the game was as you would expect between 4-7 and 0-10 teams (a 33-28 final that was 22-17 after 3 quarters).

Eastshire Wed Jan 19, 2011 10:26am

Quote:

Originally Posted by RichMSN (Post 718976)
GV last night. I went over to the table with about 11 minutes left. (Captains at 12 minutes here and to the table right afterwards. May have been 11:15 or so on the clock when I walked over.) Noticed the visiting scorer was copying the official book. No biggy, I have other things to do.

So I chatted with the timer (the BV coach and a fine baseball umpire), took a bunch of air out of the basketball (it bounced up to my neck when I dropped it), and checked the possession arrows, etc. I also found out that a good sportsmanship report I sent after a previous game was read and appreciated by all -- I didn't even know it had been published.

With about 7 minutes on the clock, I finally got the official book and immediately noticed that the starters weren't marked. Actually, there were numbers next to the players and I thought that the ones marked "1" were the starters, so I asked the timer (as a coach, I figured he'd set me straight). He immediately called over the GV coach and brusquely told him that he needed to designate his starters. Whoops. The coach went down the list and picked five players as if he really didn't know who he was starting. Maybe he was just looking for the names in the book.

In the meantime, I signed the other book (the visiting scorer was nowhere to be found) and I had the timer enter the scorers in that book as well. I passed on assessing the technical foul, mainly because I would've had that fixed at 11 minutes had the book not been in the hands of the visiting scorer.

So, question for the group: Would it be better at 11 minutes to say to the visiting scorer -- "I need the official book for a minute and I'll give it right back to you" or simply do what I did? This little voice inside my head says I should've taken the book at 11 minutes just in case the visiting coach/scorer had made a big deal about this. As it was, we had no problems and the game was as you would expect between 4-7 and 0-10 teams (a 33-28 final that was 22-17 after 3 quarters).

This is why I like to check the book at 14 and then do the captain's meeting at 12, although most in this area check the book when you do.

Yes, I'd take the book from the visiting scorer and check it then as he has at least 10 minutes to finish after you are done.

Rich Wed Jan 19, 2011 10:35am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Eastshire (Post 719003)
This is why I like to check the book at 14 and then do the captain's meeting at 12, although most in this area check the book when you do.

Yes, I'd take the book from the visiting scorer and check it then as he has at least 10 minutes to finish after you are done.

If we went over at 14 minutes, the book wouldn't be done. Here we do captain meeting at 12 and go to the table right after. It's a well known protocol in the state. Even then, we frequently run into timers/scorers that are not at the table.

Smitty Wed Jan 19, 2011 11:06am

If the official book is ready and the visitor is copying the info, I will ask them to let me borrow it for a minute while I do my thing. Sometimes they give me the stink eye, but that's not really my problem. There will be plenty of time for them to finish copying the info when I bring it back.

Jurassic Referee Wed Jan 19, 2011 11:07am

Quote:

Originally Posted by RichMSN (Post 718976)
.......took a bunch of air out of the basketball (it bounced up to my neck when I dropped it........

???:confused:

That's about right, isn't it? The ball is supposed to bounce up to between 49 and 54 inches. That's neck-high for you, isn't it?



<font size = -4>Just couldn't help myself :D </font>

mbyron Wed Jan 19, 2011 11:23am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jurassic Referee (Post 719037)
???:confused:

That's about right, isn't it? The ball is supposed to bounce up to between 49 and 54 inches. That's neck-high for you, isn't it?



<font size = -4>Just couldn't help myself :D </font>

Bad Woddy! Bad, bad Woddy!

mj Wed Jan 19, 2011 11:24am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Smitty (Post 719035)
If the official book is ready and the visitor is copying the info, I will ask them to let me borrow it for a minute while I do my thing. Sometimes they give me the stink eye, but that's not really my problem. There will be plenty of time for them to finish copying the info when I bring it back.

Same here.

mbyron Wed Jan 19, 2011 11:25am

Quote:

Originally Posted by RichMSN (Post 718976)
This little voice inside my head says I should've taken the book at 11 minutes just in case the visiting coach/scorer had made a big deal about this.

I wouldn't advise this in general, but in this case listen to the little voice. Who gets in trouble if they're still working on the book at 8:00, you or the scorer?

Rich Wed Jan 19, 2011 12:11pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by mbyron (Post 719055)
I wouldn't advise this in general, but in this case listen to the little voice. Who gets in trouble if they're still working on the book at 8:00, you or the scorer?

Well, to be honest, neither (in this case). I knew in that environment I could do pretty much whatever I wanted and nobody was going to say anything. I am kinda fond of following the rules, though.

SCalScoreKeeper Wed Jan 19, 2011 02:57pm

That's exactly why I prep my Varsity Girls scorebook during the JV boys game.
All R has to do is count up players and match to teams and sign the book.Speaking of the practice of having R sign the book below the last listed player so that no more can be added-how many areas use this practice?

Eastshire Wed Jan 19, 2011 02:58pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by SCalScoreKeeper (Post 719209)
That's exactly why I prep my Varsity Girls scorebook during the JV boys game.
All R has to do is count up players and match to teams and sign the book.Speaking of the practice of having R sign the book below the last listed player so that no more can be added-how many areas use this practice?

The practice here is to right the number of names in the book in the space below the last name and to draw a line through the remain spaces.

SCalScoreKeeper Wed Jan 19, 2011 03:00pm

Here its draw a line through the remaining spaces and R initials both sides!

Smitty Wed Jan 19, 2011 03:29pm

Round here we have the coaches sign the book under their roster.

Welpe Wed Jan 19, 2011 03:41pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Smitty (Post 719249)
Round here we have the coaches sign the book under their roster.

I've taken to doing the same.

BktBallRef Wed Jan 19, 2011 04:20pm

As we rarely have a single game at a site, I think the book has been ready at the 10 minute mark exactly one time this year. It's not something I can worry about.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:10am.



Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.3.0 RC1