Messy situation

[Camron Rust]

After the T, the other team got possession, are we going to cancel the points they scored on that possession or cancel the PC foul committed by their team on that possession...all under the premise that it was a bookkeeping error and everything that followed from it was erroneous?

[Judtech]

Originally Posted by Camron Rust

After the T, the other team got possession, are we going to cancel the points they scored on that possession or cancel the PC foul committed by their team on that possession...all under the premise that it was a bookkeeping error and everything that followed from it was erroneous?

You mean a "Do Over"?

[rockyroad]

Originally Posted by Camron Rust

After the T, the other team got possession, are we going to cancel the points they scored on that possession or cancel the PC foul committed by their team on that possession...all under the premise that it was a bookkeeping error and everything that followed from it was erroneous?

WTF are you talking about? The Op'er was very clear that the Visiting Coach brought the roster issue to their attention as soon as the second free throw was shot...so you're just making crap up now? For what purpose?

In the OP, it was a bookkeeping error that led to unmerited free throws - the time frame is intact. Fix it.

[Camron Rust]

Originally Posted by rockyroad

WTF are you talking about? The Op'er was very clear that the Visiting Coach brought the roster issue to their attention as soon as the second free throw was shot...so you're just making crap up now? For what purpose?

In the OP, it was a bookkeeping error that led to unmerited free throws - the time frame is intact. Fix it.

There were people, not the OP, referenced by Snaqwells claiming they'd cancel the T and maybe other consequences at any time, even minutes/quarters later. THAT is what I was talking about.

I agree that it can be fixed up to a point...and that exact point is clearly debateable. I believe it to be when the first FT is taken. I could accept that it could be later...as late as the normal correctable error limits....no later. After that, there is no going back and changing anything except for perhaps the number of timeouts remaining.

[deecee]

assuming no other action has taken place and its just been free throws I would wipe the fts off as well.

[mj]

Originally Posted by deecee

assuming no other action has taken place and its just been free throws I would wipe the fts off as well.

I would handle it the same way.

[Indianaref]

Originally Posted by Camron Rust

After the T, the other team got possession, are we going to cancel the points they scored on that possession or cancel the PC foul committed by their team on that possession...all under the premise that it was a bookkeeping error and everything that followed from it was erroneous?

Can an "do over" argument be made that 10.1.8 Comment is a specific case play where a field goal and common fouls are cancelled.

[Camron Rust]

Originally Posted by Indianaref

Can an "do over" argument be made that 10.1.8 Comment is a specific case play where a field goal and common fouls are cancelled.

No, in that case team A, having just scored, threw in a dead ball and scored a dead ball. The ball would have only become live had team B taken it OOB for the throwin.