Messy situation

[Raymond]

Originally Posted by zm1283

It is penalized when the infraction occurs, which is when the player enters the game. The HC is asking the scorer to add his player to the book when the player enters the game.

Am I reading 10.1.2b completely wrong? It seems fairly specific. I had this play happen two years ago and called the technical and was corrected when I posted about it here.

You are interpreting it wrong. The infraction is for entering the name into the book. The name is not yet in the book and wasn't on the submitted roster (even though in hindsight you said it was).

Originally Posted by zm1283

So what is the difference between "occurs" and "discovered" in 10-1-2? Is the case play 10.1.2b wrong?

In the case play the name was entered into the book and the ball became live before discovered by the officials.