The Official Forum

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)
-   Basketball (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/)
-   -   Boxing Out!!!! (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/5688-boxing-out.html)

jumpball6 Mon Aug 26, 2002 05:20pm

Once you wonder about a call during a game it happens all the time... I need clarificaiton on a rule and where to find it. Here we go... If a ball is going out of bounds on either a shot, pass or loose ball can the player that didn't touch the ball last continue to box out a player that is going for the ball to keep it in play???

zebraman Mon Aug 26, 2002 05:53pm

Sure...as long as they do not commit a foul in doing so.

Z

mick Mon Aug 26, 2002 08:27pm

Proceed with caution!
 
Quote:

Originally posted by jumpball6
Once you wonder about a call during a game it happens all the time... I need clarificaiton on a rule and where to find it. Here we go... If a ball is going out of bounds on either a shot, pass or loose ball can the player that didn't touch the ball last continue to box out a player that is going for the ball to keep it in play???
jumpball6,
We may have a foul on the illegal screen, or a push on the player behind, but use good judgment when calling a foul in this sitch. That is, make sure it's a foul and not merely incidental contact.
mick

BktBallRef Mon Aug 26, 2002 10:23pm

Each player is entitled to his place on the floor as long as he legally obtained it. If he moves to prevent the player behind from getting the around him, he's guilty of blokcing. But like mick said, I'd be very careful about calling it. Did he really have a chance to save the ball? Was the contact legal?

bob jenkins Mon Aug 26, 2002 10:33pm

Quote:

Originally posted by jumpball6
Once you wonder about a call during a game it happens all the time... I need clarificaiton on a rule and where to find it. Here we go... If a ball is going out of bounds on either a shot, pass or loose ball can the player that didn't touch the ball last continue to box out a player that is going for the ball to keep it in play???
It's just a screen -- apply those rules.

rainmaker Mon Aug 26, 2002 11:02pm

It's NOT like soccer, where the ref can call "obstruction" for stepping into the opponent's path without playing the ball. In basketball, that kind of play is completely legal as long as there is no illegal contact.

eroe39 Tue Aug 27, 2002 03:02am

Jumpball6, I agree with Bob that you would treat it as a screen. Be careful Rainmaker, because a player cannot step into an opponent's path without giving that opponent time and distance to avoid contact. Since neither one of these players have the ball time and distance is critical. Obviously, if an opponent had the ball then time and distance would not have to be given by the defender. Now to be in line with the previous responses I would agree that you would want to be careful on this call. Only call if obvious and you really believe the player could have saved the ball. Or call if violent or looks real ugly even if the player could not save the ball.

rainmaker Wed Aug 28, 2002 02:48am

Quote:

Originally posted by eroe39
Be careful Rainmaker, because a player cannot step into an opponent's path without giving that opponent time and distance to avoid contact.
You're right, but if there's no contact, it's not a foul, for instance if the other player dodges, or stops. I'm not recommending that players should be stepping into each other's paths willy-nilly, just pointing out that the ref can't call anything if there's no contact. In soccer, a foul can be called without contact, if the stepper-in is just trying to body-block, without playing the ball. At least, at some levels.

dblref Wed Aug 28, 2002 05:45am

Quote:

Originally posted by rainmaker
Quote:

Originally posted by eroe39
Be careful Rainmaker, because a player cannot step into an opponent's path without giving that opponent time and distance to avoid contact.
You're right, but if there's no contact, it's not a foul, for instance if the other player dodges, or stops. I'm not recommending that players should be stepping into each other's paths willy-nilly, just pointing out that the ref can't call anything if there's no contact. In soccer, a foul can be called without contact, if the stepper-in is just trying to body-block, without playing the ball. At least, at some levels.

Just a small point of clarification -- I think I remember this from my soccer referee days. If the ball is going "out of touch" - i.e., going out of bounds, you can legally screen an opponent from the ball as long as you do not hold your opponent. Obstruction should not be called if the ball is within playing distance. You do not have to play the ball, it just has to be within "playing distance".

rainmaker Wed Aug 28, 2002 12:27pm

Quote:

Originally posted by dblref
Just a small point of clarification -- I think I remember this from my soccer referee days. If the ball is going "out of touch" - i.e., going out of bounds, you can legally screen an opponent from the ball as long as you do not hold your opponent. Obstruction should not be called if the ball is within playing distance. You do not have to play the ball, it just has to be within "playing distance".
Thanks for the clarification. I have never reffed soccer, but my husband has played semi-pro in the past and we compare rules from time to time -- current hoop rules set up next to 20-year-old footer rules. My only other soccer experience is being thrown off the field for yelling at the refs at my sons games (yes, I am one of THOSE parents!!)

Mark T. DeNucci, Sr. Wed Aug 28, 2002 02:15pm

Quote:

Originally posted by rainmaker
Quote:

Originally posted by eroe39
Be careful Rainmaker, because a player cannot step into an opponent's path without giving that opponent time and distance to avoid contact.
You're right, but if there's no contact, it's not a foul, for instance if the other player dodges, or stops. I'm not recommending that players should be stepping into each other's paths willy-nilly, just pointing out that the ref can't call anything if there's no contact. In soccer, a foul can be called without contact, if the stepper-in is just trying to body-block, without playing the ball. At least, at some levels.


I love to tell a coach that obstruction is only a foul in soccer. He keeps their mouths shut for about 30 sec.

bigwhistle Wed Aug 28, 2002 10:30pm

now you did it
 
I knew you two talking about soccer would wake up the sleeping giant!

BktBallRef Wed Aug 28, 2002 11:01pm

Quote:

Originally posted by rainmaker
My only other soccer experience is being thrown off the field for yelling at the refs at my sons games (yes, I am one of THOSE parents!!)
You should be ashamed! http://www.stopstart.fsnet.co.uk/mica/Miscguy2.gif

devdog69 Thu Aug 29, 2002 06:49am

In keeping on the subject, ;) (for Todd)

Sitch: B1 is following a ball that is going out of bounds last touched by A1, he is obviously going to let it go and is making no attempt to save it. A2 comes running at full speed, going to sacrifice his body by saving the ball and going into the stands. At the last possible second B1 notices him and takes a step to the right into the path of A2 who has no chance to keep from plowing B1 into the stands. We have a block on B1 right?


Ref in PA Thu Aug 29, 2002 07:04am

devdog69:
 
If B1 did not give A2 a chance to avoid B1, I have a block on B1. Books defines chance as a step. You have to see the play, but what you described sounds like a block.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 12:31pm.



Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.3.0 RC1