The Official Forum

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)
-   Basketball (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/)
-   -   Major upset in women's tourney (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/52487-major-upset-womens-tourney.html)

Ref Ump Welsch Mon Mar 23, 2009 02:31pm

I should have taken my buddy's bet on this. He said he'd give me $100 bucks for each round further from the championship game Tennessee gets knocked out, with noone paying out if they lost the championship game. I would have had to pay him $500 if they won it all. This first round loss would have won $500 for me. I should have taken him on it because I knew Tenn wouldn't make it all the way! *smacking myself in the head till I bleed*

JRutledge Mon Mar 23, 2009 02:51pm

Wow, you got me by a few years. Wooden teams went undefeated in 72 and 73. :rolleyes:

And the point being made is upsets happen every year in the Men's tournament. This is the first year ever that high seeds in multiple regions made it to the Sweet 16. All but one region has the 1, 2, 3 and 4 seeds advance. The other region had a 5 beat a 4 seed. That happens almost every year in women’s basketball or the final for has mostly top seeds. Not very common that a team not expected to make the Final Four or from a mid-major conference makes it to the Final Four or Regional Championship. If UConn wins the NC this year, it will be the 4th time in recent history that an undefeated team wins the NC. That has not come close to happening in over 30 years on the Men's side. And it never happened in the current seeding structure. When Wooden was doing it, they did not have to beat teams from other regions to make the Final Four.

Once again, very little talk about the actual games or plays, just a debate about relevance. If you have to talk about relevance and not the game, that proves the point I been making all along. And if you do not want people to comment in that way, just post a thread about the game and leave it at that.

Peace

w_sohl Mon Mar 23, 2009 02:52pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by JRutledge (Post 590764)
The other region had a 5 beat a 4 seed.

Thanks to my Boilermakers!!!!

rockyroad Mon Mar 23, 2009 03:07pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by w_sohl (Post 590765)
Thanks to my Boilermakers!!!!

Stupid Boilermakers!

This is a huge upset in the Women's game. Good for Ball State. And Tenn will be back next year, I'm sure.

Rutledge - just quit reading any of the threads on Women's basketball. Every time someone posts something you have to turn it into your argument about relevance. Then you keep bringing the thread back to your argument aboaut relevance. If it isn't relevant to you, shut the he!! up and let others discuss it if they want to.

Again - congrats to Ball State.

JRutledge Mon Mar 23, 2009 03:24pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by rockyroad (Post 590769)

Rutledge - just quit reading any of the threads on Women's basketball. Every time someone posts something you have to turn it into your argument about relevance. Then you keep bringing the thread back to your argument aboaut relevance. If it isn't relevant to you, shut the he!! up and let others discuss it if they want to.

Juulie has been getting huffy and puffy over this topic for years. She got upset when it was discussed on the chat room that was developed for the tournament the last couple of years. She went out of her way to claim that she was not excited about the Men's tournament but the Women's tournament was what she was excited about (and no one asked about what we thought). And she claimed one of the reasons she left was because people put down women's or girl's basketball. If you do not want what you perceive negative comments, then do not bring up people's names and do not comment in a place you claim is hostile to your opinion. If you have not noticed, I will say what I want and do not care what others feel about those comments. And if I do not feel like talking about something, I do not bring it up. See how easy that is to do? ;)

Peace

Rich Mon Mar 23, 2009 03:26pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by rockyroad (Post 590769)
Stupid Boilermakers!

This is a huge upset in the Women's game. Good for Ball State. And Tenn will be back next year, I'm sure.

Rutledge - just quit reading any of the threads on Women's basketball. Every time someone posts something you have to turn it into your argument about relevance. Then you keep bringing the thread back to your argument aboaut relevance. If it isn't relevant to you, shut the he!! up and let others discuss it if they want to.

Again - congrats to Ball State.

To be fair, the OP is the one that brought Jeff into this thread. Something tells me he wouldn't have posted at all otherwise.

Raymond Mon Mar 23, 2009 03:34pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by RichMSN (Post 590772)
To be fair, the OP is the one that brought Jeff into this thread. Something tells me he wouldn't have posted at all otherwise.

I'm surprised he opened the thread in the first place. Otherwise he wouldn't have seen his name. :p

JRutledge Mon Mar 23, 2009 03:49pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by RichMSN (Post 590772)
To be fair, the OP is the one that brought Jeff into this thread. Something tells me he wouldn't have posted at all otherwise.

Right.

Quote:

Originally Posted by BadNewsRef (Post 590779)
I'm surprised he opened the thread in the first place. Otherwise he wouldn't have seen his name. :p

It would have likely been the only time I would have seen the news on the upset. I was kind of hoping that UConn got beat.

Peace

rockyroad Mon Mar 23, 2009 04:01pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by RichMSN (Post 590772)
To be fair, the OP is the one that brought Jeff into this thread. Something tells me he wouldn't have posted at all otherwise.

OK, in that case I apologize Jeff. I didn't realize that you were drug into this kicking and screaming. What I get for not reading the entire thread first.

M&M Guy Mon Mar 23, 2009 04:08pm

For the life of me, I just can't remember the second verse to Kumbya...

But I do feel all warm and squishy inside with all the love being thrown around.

:D

JRutledge Mon Mar 23, 2009 04:10pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by rockyroad (Post 590793)
OK, in that case I apologize Jeff. I didn't realize that you were drug into this kicking and screaming. What I get for not reading the entire thread first.

Someone does not have to be dragged to do anything. But if you start off by complaining, then do not get mad when someone addresses your complaint. ;)

Peace

Adam Mon Mar 23, 2009 04:22pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by M&M Guy (Post 590799)
For the life of me, I just can't remember the second verse to Kumbya...

But I do feel all warm and squishy inside with all the love being thrown around.

:D

That's the seafood you had last night.

Juulie Downs Mon Mar 23, 2009 04:58pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by JRutledge (Post 590771)
Juulie has been getting huffy and puffy over this topic for years. She got upset when it was discussed on the chat room that was developed for the tournament the last couple of years. She went out of her way to claim that she was not excited about the Men's tournament but the Women's tournament was what she was excited about (and no one asked about what we thought).

I just went out of my way to say that the beginning of the men's tournament wasn't the high point of the year. Women's basketball wasn't the only issue I raised, btw. Mostly I was just trying to razz Nevada a little.

I mostly don't get huffy and puffy about people disliking women's ball. I do get way past frustrated when that dislike turns into belittling women and girls. Which you never did, Jeff, btw, but others did.

Also, I'm perfectly willing to disagree about which is more difficult to ref, women's or men's, but in the past it's always ended up with mud-slinging and flaming and I didn't just go away from that, but tried to defend myself. That was my mistake, and I left when I realized that there was going to be no way I could change the culture or tenor of this board to actively omit that stuff.

Quote:

Originally Posted by JRutledge (Post 590771)
And she claimed one of the reasons she left was because people put down women's or girl's basketball.

There were plenty of put downs of women's or girl's basketball, but that wasn't the reason I left, but I"m not going to go into that here. It's just not a constructive topic.

Quote:

Originally Posted by JRutledge (Post 590771)
If you do not want what you perceive negative comments, then do not bring up people's names and do not comment in a place you claim is hostile to your opinion.

I was simply responding to your comment that there weren't upsets in the women's tournament. I was simply pointing out that while you may or may not be right overall, here was a big upset that happened very, very shortly after your comment. Just kinda interesting.

Quote:

If you have not noticed, I will say what I want and do not care what others feel about those comments. And if I do not feel like talking about something, I do not bring it up. See how easy that is to do?
I certainly don't mind you expressing your opinions. But it IS frustrating when you claim to be dragged into something that actually, you started. Just saying...

JRutledge Mon Mar 23, 2009 05:16pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Juulie Downs (Post 590830)
Also, I'm perfectly willing to disagree about which is more difficult to ref, women's or men's, but in the past it's always ended up with mud-slinging and flaming and I didn't just go away from that, but tried to defend myself. That was my mistake, and I left when I realized that there was going to be no way I could change the culture or tenor of this board to actively omit that stuff.

There were plenty of put downs of women's or girl's basketball, but that wasn't the reason I left, but I"m not going to go into that here. It's just not a constructive topic.

OK. I was only referencing things you had said. I am sure there was more to the situation than what you said. I do tend to understand context. ;) And it is certainly true that the comments were not just from me.


Quote:

Originally Posted by Juulie Downs (Post 590830)
I was simply responding to your comment that there weren't upsets in the women's tournament. I was simply pointing out that while you may or may not be right overall, here was a big upset that happened very, very shortly after your comment. Just kinda interesting.

I would understand if I said, "There never…ever is ever an upset in women's basketball." That is the farthest thing from what I have said. I said that there is not the same level of upsets as compared to the Men's side. And without getting into much detail, the information is out there. And I have won a few pools simply by picking mostly the top seeds and winning. Last year was the first time in Men's Tourney history that all top seeds made the Final Four. It is not unusual that the Men's top seeds may not make the Final Four. That was really the point I was making. That has nothing to do with putting down Women's basketball. That is stating things they talk about on ESPN all the time.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Juulie Downs (Post 590830)
I certainly don't mind you expressing your opinions. But it IS frustrating when you claim to be dragged into something that actually, you started. Just saying...

Juulie, I did not start the thread, you did. I did not come here saying "See I was right." And if you did not mention my name, I would not have said a word. And after this thread is over, I likely will not comment again until maybe the Final Four, which I sometimes watch because nothing else is going on (I am not a big early season baseball fan).

Raymond Tue Mar 24, 2009 07:32am

Were there any upsets Monday?


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 02:31pm.



Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.3.0 RC1