The Official Forum

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)
-   Basketball (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/)
-   -   First Time Ever - T to start game (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/51040-first-time-ever-t-start-game.html)

ranjo Sun Jan 18, 2009 10:41pm

First Time Ever - T to start game
 
Happened in a JV boys game last night -

As my partner and I go over to meet and greet the visiting coach, he is at the table and his scorer is erasing something in the book. We ask what he is doing, and he explains that he is changing his starters. We tell him that if he does that, it is a technical foul as is is way past the 10 minute mark. He responds with "Then just give us the technical because there's no way these guys are starting". He then asks if it is charged to him or just to the team and we tell him it is only a team foul and he still has use of his box.

We inform the home coach we are starting the game with a technical foul and then the visiting varsity coach comes over to tell us that its not right to start the game that way - That it had happened before this season and the officials let it go. We don't buy into his story and tell him two wrongs don't make a right.

So instead of a jump ball at center court, we award two free throws to the home team, give them the ball for a throw-in, set the arrow to the visitors, and continue the game.

Its one of those things you read about, but in all these years it is the first time I have seen or had it actually happen. You can only imagine how perplexed the spectators were, trying to figure out what was going on. I think all of us missed the anticipation of the jump ball going up!

How many of you have actually started with a technical for anything other than dunking in warm-ups?

rockyroad Sun Jan 18, 2009 11:02pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by ranjo (Post 569925)
How many of you have actually started with a technical for anything other than dunking in warm-ups?

Had it last night also. Didn't have starters in the book, and no one out on the court warming up - they went to their locker room before we came out and weren't back before we left at 10:00. No biggie - they messed up. This was in an NCAA game, so we shot the two shots and then still got to toss it up.:p

Scrapper1 Sun Jan 18, 2009 11:03pm

I've had it happen. Coach gave the wrong jersey numbers to the scorer. Had to change the whole roster when the team came out for the jump. Oh well.

Stat-Man Sun Jan 18, 2009 11:43pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by rockyroad (Post 569933)
Had it last night also. Didn't have starters in the book, and no one out on the court warming up - they went to their locker room before we came out and weren't back before we left at 10:00. No biggie - they messed up. This was in an NCAA game, so we shot the two shots and then still got to toss it up.:p

I wish you were the official at a game I was at a few years back. NCAA-W. Visiting team leaves the floor at ~12 minutes to go and visiting coach never gives her starting 5. Team returns to the floor with 5 mins to go and she finally gives tsarters and tells the table it's their job to go get her in the locker room if she hasn't given them starters. :confused: She got no T. :mad:

###

When I was in college, we got a T to start the game because in the previous game, we had a player not play for whaetever reason, and I had copied our lineup from the sheet without him. and given that to the home scorer. One of my firends played for the opponent and he still teases me about that. :P

Nevadaref Sun Jan 18, 2009 11:55pm

Yes, I had a game in which a starter was wearing 00, but was listed as 0.

I wrote a thread about it on here and it generated quite a response.

http://forum.officiating.com/showthread.php?t=18053

agr8zebra Mon Jan 19, 2009 12:31am

I have started atleast a game a year with FT's, Once for dunking.

We as officials just have to treat T's as just another foul, it is no big deal, especially to start a game. If more officials would give a T when it is warranted instead of talking or warning until certain activities would soon cease to occur.

Rich Mon Jan 19, 2009 02:02am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nevadaref (Post 569952)
Yes, I had a game in which a starter was wearing 00, but was listed as 0.

I wrote a thread about it on here and it generated quite a response.

http://forum.officiating.com/showthread.php?t=18053

And you are still wrong. :D

There are three kinds of mathematicians in the world: Those that can count and those that can't.

--Rich (BS, Mathematics)

mbyron Mon Jan 19, 2009 09:00am

Quote:

Originally Posted by ranjo (Post 569925)
We tell him that if he does that, it is a technical foul as is is way past the 10 minute mark. He responds with "Then just give us the technical because there's no way these guys are starting".

His response would lead me to a follow-up question: did he provide a correct roster to the scorekeeper, who misidentified the starters when entering the players in the book?

If so, then the T would not have been correct.

ranjo Mon Jan 19, 2009 11:15am

Quote:

Originally Posted by mbyron (Post 570023)
His response would lead me to a follow-up question: did he provide a correct roster to the scorekeeper, who misidentified the starters when entering the players in the book?


Nope!

Mark Padgett Mon Jan 19, 2009 11:51am

Quote:

Originally Posted by ranjo (Post 569925)
How many of you have actually started with a technical for anything other than dunking in warm-ups?

I had one game in which I ejected both head coaches before the game began for looking at me cross-eyed. The assistant coaches were also tossed just because I felt like it, so we couldn't play the game. There was a really good show on TV that night and my DVR was already full. :cool:

BTW - I once started with a technical for pre-game dunking in a 3rd grade girls game. And if you believe that, you're probably betting on the Lions to win the Super Bowl. :p

Also, can you tell I lost my meds? :o

Man In Blue Mon Jan 19, 2009 11:58am

Quote:

Originally Posted by ranjo (Post 569925)
Happened in a JV boys game last night -

As my partner and I go over to meet and greet the visiting coach, he is at the table and his scorer is erasing something in the book. We ask what he is doing, and he explains that he is changing his starters. We tell him that if he does that, it is a technical foul as is is way past the 10 minute mark. He responds with "Then just give us the technical because there's no way these guys are starting". He then asks if it is charged to him or just to the team and we tell him it is only a team foul and he still has use of his box.

We inform the home coach we are starting the game with a technical foul and then the visiting varsity coach comes over to tell us that its not right to start the game that way - That it had happened before this season and the officials let it go. We don't buy into his story and tell him two wrongs don't make a right.

So instead of a jump ball at center court, we award two free throws to the home team, give them the ball for a throw-in, set the arrow to the visitors, and continue the game.

Its one of those things you read about, but in all these years it is the first time I have seen or had it actually happen. You can only imagine how perplexed the spectators were, trying to figure out what was going on. I think all of us missed the anticipation of the jump ball going up!

How many of you have actually started with a technical for anything other than dunking in warm-ups?

Are you sure this is how you want to handle a JV game? I am a by the book kind of guy but this seems excessive to me. Especially if the coach wants to change starters to send a message to his team.

Varsity game I am all over this and access the T. Sub-varsity I am asking coach what's up?

In my part of the world sub-varsity is about getting kids on the court. Often there are different uniforms, possibly 2 number 5's etc. As long as the coach explains what is happening there should be a little slack.

I am not saying that I would pass on playing rules, etc but fashion police can take a back seat for common sense.

Besides what advantage did the coach gain?

refnrev Mon Jan 19, 2009 12:04pm

[QUOTE=ranjo;569925]Happened in a JV boys game last night -

JV game I'm not starting with the T. Let them fix it quickly and let it go. V game, nail him, but that's just me.

Raymond Mon Jan 19, 2009 12:09pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Man In Blue (Post 570087)
Are you sure this is how you want to handle a JV game? I am a by the book kind of guy but this seems excessive to me. Especially if the coach wants to change starters to send a message to his team.

Varsity game I am all over this and access the T. Sub-varsity I am asking coach what's up?

In my part of the world sub-varsity is about getting kids on the court. Often there are different uniforms, possibly 2 number 5's etc. As long as the coach explains what is happening there should be a little slack.

I am not saying that I would pass on playing rules, etc but fashion police can take a back seat for common sense.

And in Ranjo's game the JV coach had no problem with accepting the consequences of his actions. It only became a problem when the Varsity coach stuck his nose in where it didn't belong.

Besides what advantage did the coach gain?

In Ranjo's world JV basketball is very well organized and they are expected to follow the same rules as varsity. The VHSL does however allow an exception for the "home team must wear white" rule.

And when a coach changes his starters after the 10 minute mark we are now suppose to let it go if he is doing it to "send his team a message"?

Man In Blue Mon Jan 19, 2009 12:24pm

What is the intent of the rule?

I think it to stop coaches from making changes on starters up to the start of the game. A coach would be looking to find the best match ups. The rule also eliminates confusion at the table to start the game.

Again it maybe different parts of the country but here there is a big difference between varsity and sub-varsity.

Scratch85 Mon Jan 19, 2009 01:23pm

[QUOTE=refnrev;570090]
Quote:

Originally Posted by ranjo (Post 569925)
Happened in a JV boys game last night -

JV game I'm not starting with the T. Let them fix it quickly and let it go. V game, nail him, but that's just me.

I try to treat JV games just like I do V games. Below that, I make a few exceptions. 99% of JV games are right before the V game, with V coaches on the bench and some players who will be participatiing in both games. I do not want to send mixed messages.

I also believe that intentionally not applying rules is a great way to forget how to apply those rules.

dan74 Mon Jan 19, 2009 01:38pm

How do you report a pre-start T. Let's say a player dunks five minutes before the start or a coach makes a change to the book within ten minutes, how do you make the call?

Do you just verbalize it to the table and then to the coaches individually, or do you actually signal the T somewhere, like in front of the table or do you do so from the foul reporting area. Do you call the T right when the violation happens, or wait until the pre-game clock runs down to zero and then call it?

Mark Padgett Mon Jan 19, 2009 01:43pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by dan74 (Post 570133)
How do you report a pre-start T. Let's say a player dunks five minutes before the start or a coach makes a change to the book within ten minutes, how do you make the call?

Do you just verbalize it to the table and then to the coaches individually, or do you actually signal the T somewhere, like in front of the table or do you do so from the foul reporting area. Do you call the T right when the violation happens, or wait until the pre-game clock runs down to zero and then call it?

You use the proper mechanic which is to take the stuffed dummy of the coach and brand a "T" on its forehead. You then string the dummy up by throwing a rope over the rear support behind that team's basket. Then report it to the table in pig-latin.

Then you try to find your meds. :o

ranjo Mon Jan 19, 2009 02:15pm

[QUOTE=refnrev;570090]
Quote:

Originally Posted by ranjo (Post 569925)
Happened in a JV boys game last night -

JV game I'm not starting with the T. Let them fix it quickly and let it go. V game, nail him, but that's just me.


The coach was given an opportunity to fix it, but he chose the technical over changing the starters back to the ones originally checked off in the book.

ranjo Mon Jan 19, 2009 02:22pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by BadNewsRef (Post 570092)
In Ranjo's world JV basketball is very well organized and they are expected to follow the same rules as varsity. The VHSL does however allow an exception for the "home team must wear white" rule.

Just to add a note, a few of our AAA JV boys teams are playing above the rim. When you throw it up, be prepared to run hard for 32 minutes. I would never turn back one of the JV boys games in our area.

mbyron Mon Jan 19, 2009 02:52pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by ranjo (Post 570143)
Just to add a note, a few of our AAA JV boys teams are playing above the rim. When you throw it up, be prepared to run hard for 32 minutes. I would never turn back one of the JV boys games in our area.

You play 8 minute quarters for JV? :eek:

bob jenkins Mon Jan 19, 2009 03:04pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by dan74 (Post 570133)
How do you report a pre-start T. Let's say a player dunks five minutes before the start or a coach makes a change to the book within ten minutes, how do you make the call?

Do you just verbalize it to the table and then to the coaches individually, or do you actually signal the T somewhere, like in front of the table or do you do so from the foul reporting area. Do you call the T right when the violation happens, or wait until the pre-game clock runs down to zero and then call it?

I had a kid hang on the rim in pre-game Saturday night. I escorted him to his coach and made him explain why we would be starting with a T. Then, I (we) made sure the books had it right and knew when and how to set the arrow, etc., and told the opposing coach that his team would start with FTs.

The announcer announced, "We're starting the game with FTs due to a technical foul on xxxx team during the pre-game."

On we went.

zm1283 Mon Jan 19, 2009 03:27pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by mbyron (Post 570160)
You play 8 minute quarters for JV? :eek:

Some of the bigger schools around here do, and especially during tournaments.

steve33 Mon Jan 19, 2009 03:30pm

Coaching we've had two situations like this already this season, both handled differently. (btw, NJCAA-W game)

First game, official scorebook wasn't even at the table until 5 minutes before tip-off. Officials gave them (the home team) an Administrative technical foul for not having a book. Our best FT shooter wasn't starting that day, but was able to shoot the 2, and then go back to the bench. However, they still had a jump ball to start the game. Wasn't sure if you set the arrow or jump in NCAA rules, but it wasn't a big deal since we got to start the game up 2-0 :D

Second game happened this weekend. The home team put 7 players in their book, and ended up playing 9. When we saw they were using a new player, we notified the officials and they said it was no big deal. Our HC got so upset he started going off. Luckily the officials did not T him up for his demonstration.

(BTW, these guys also waved off 5 three pointers because the 20'9" line is the "College" line and the 19'9" is the "High School" line.) :mad::rolleyes:

dbking Mon Jan 19, 2009 03:34pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Man In Blue (Post 570087)
Are you sure this is how you want to handle a JV game? I am a by the book kind of guy but this seems excessive to me. Especially if the coach wants to change starters to send a message to his team.

Varsity game I am all over this and access the T. Sub-varsity I am asking coach what's up?

In my part of the world sub-varsity is about getting kids on the court. Often there are different uniforms, possibly 2 number 5's etc. As long as the coach explains what is happening there should be a little slack.

I am not saying that I would pass on playing rules, etc but fashion police can take a back seat for common sense.

Besides what advantage did the coach gain?

I am with Blue, below varsity, almost anything goes with all of the pregame house keeping rules. I am happy if we have a scorekeeper and clock operator that knows what they are doing and not texting.

refnrev Mon Jan 19, 2009 03:37pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by mbyron (Post 570160)
You play 8 minute quarters for JV? :eek:

All of them around here do.

deecee Mon Jan 19, 2009 03:39pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by mbyron (Post 570160)
You play 8 minute quarters for JV? :eek:

Not just 8 minutes for JV but also for Freshmen in SoCal.

ranjo Mon Jan 19, 2009 06:19pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by mbyron (Post 570160)
You play 8 minute quarters for JV? :eek:

JV boys & JV girls.

DonInKansas Mon Jan 19, 2009 06:39pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by ranjo (Post 570244)
JV boys & JV girls.

How it is here too.

Mark Padgett Mon Jan 19, 2009 06:41pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by mbyron (Post 570160)
You play 8 minute quarters for JV? :eek:

What do you play around there?

jdw3018 Mon Jan 19, 2009 06:53pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mark Padgett (Post 570251)
What do you play around there?

Here in SC, it's 6-minute for everything but varsity. I actually miss that about Kansas, where all HS games were 8-minute, and MS were 6-minute. Six-minute games just seem so, well, short...

BillyMac Mon Jan 19, 2009 08:10pm

Team Technical, Or Player Technical ???
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bob jenkins (Post 570164)
I had a kid hang on the rim in pre-game Saturday night. The announcer announced, "We're starting the game with FTs due to a technical foul on xxxx team during the pre-game."

I think it's a player technical foul, not a team technical foul?

NFHS Rule 10 Section 3 Player Technical: A player shall not:
ART. 3 Grasp either basket during the time of the officials’ jurisdiction, dunk or stuff, or attempt to dunk or stuff a dead ball prior to or during the game or during any intermission until jurisdiction of the officials has ended. This item applies to all team members.

Scratch85 Mon Jan 19, 2009 08:13pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mark Padgett (Post 570251)
What do you play around there?

Indiana, 8 minutes Varsity, everything else 6 minutes.

Nevadaref Mon Jan 19, 2009 08:17pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by BadNewsRef (Post 570092)
In Ranjo's world JV basketball is very well organized and they are expected to follow the same rules as varsity. The VHSL does however allow an exception for the "home team must wear white" rule.

And when a coach changes his starters after the 10 minute mark we are now suppose to let it go if he is doing it to "send his team a message"?

Why do you believe that the VHSL needs to make an exception for the non-white jerseys at the JV level?

Nevadaref Mon Jan 19, 2009 08:24pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by dan74 (Post 570133)
How do you report a pre-start T. Let's say a player dunks five minutes before the start or a coach makes a change to the book within ten minutes, how do you make the call?

Do you just verbalize it to the table and then to the coaches individually, or do you actually signal the T somewhere, like in front of the table or do you do so from the foul reporting area. Do you call the T right when the violation happens, or wait until the pre-game clock runs down to zero and then call it?

Read this:
http://forum.officiating.com/showpos...4&postcount=47

Nevadaref Mon Jan 19, 2009 08:26pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by deecee (Post 570190)
Not just 8 minutes for JV but also for Freshmen in SoCal.

The same is true in NV.

ranjo Mon Jan 19, 2009 09:16pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nevadaref (Post 570278)
Why do you believe that the VHSL needs to make an exception for the non-white jerseys at the JV level?

The reason given is that the JV teams usually get the hand-me-down uniforms from the varsity teams, so some leaway is given until the next cycle of new uniforms are ordered for the varsity.

Nevadaref Mon Jan 19, 2009 10:16pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by ranjo (Post 570299)
The reason given is that the JV teams usually get the hand-me-down uniforms from the varsity teams, so some leaway is given until the next cycle of new uniforms are ordered for the varsity.

I understand that. However, you are missing my point. Does the state of VA or the VHSL as a league have their own rule that sub-varsity programs must wear white at home? Where is the rule coming from that needs an exception? It isn't the NFHS.

SethPDX Mon Jan 19, 2009 10:27pm

I was at an NCAA game that started with a T because the division line and center circle were obscured with the team's logo. It was the first year the rule about clearly marking the lines was in the book. The school fixed it by the next game.

Adam Tue Jan 20, 2009 07:48am

Quote:

Originally Posted by mbyron (Post 570160)
You play 8 minute quarters for JV? :eek:

8 minutes around here, too.
And while I might give them an extra minute or so, if he changes starters right before tip, that's an easy call.

bob jenkins Tue Jan 20, 2009 09:08am

Quote:

Originally Posted by BillyMac (Post 570273)
I think it's a player technical foul, not a team technical foul?

Of course it is. That is how it was enforced.

ranjo Tue Jan 20, 2009 09:22am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nevadaref (Post 570318)
I understand that. However, you are missing my point. Does the state of VA or the VHSL as a league have their own rule that sub-varsity programs must wear white at home? Where is the rule coming from that needs an exception? It isn't the NFHS.

2005-05 RULE CHANGES
3-4-6 Note Beginning in 2007-08, the home team will be required to wear white jerseys and the visiting team dark jerseys.

2007-08 MAJOR EDITORIAL CHANGES
3-4-6b Implementation date reached requiring the home team to wear white jerseys. The note will be removed and a new sub-article will be added stating this requirement.

The NFHS rule book lists some exceptions for sub-varsity (i.e 5-5-1 & 5-5-3), however, uniforms are not one of them, and we are expected to enforce the same NFHS rules at both JV and Varsity levels unless the VHSL issues a directive otherwise.

Does this answer your question?

mbyron Tue Jan 20, 2009 07:29pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mark Padgett (Post 570251)
What do you play around there?

8 minutes: varsity

7 minutes: JV & frosh

6 minutes: MS


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 01:16am.



Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.3.0 RC1