|
Sun Mar 10, 2002, 08:38am
|
|||
|
|||
|
Situation (2 man Officiating mechanics)First round of the HS playoffs and the loser goes home...Team A ahead by 3 with 7.2 seconds to go and shooting 2 freethrows...Team A has 4 players back on defense, none near the FT shooter...Team B has all 5 with the FT shooter, 3 table side and two opposite the table
Shooter misses the first shot...The Lead takes the missed shot and as he does two Team B players begin to wave their arms going from down below the waist to directly over their heads...This is to encourage the crowd to yell louder...Lead tosses shooter the ball and one of the two Team B players ceases waving but the other does not...The Team B player still waving is on the baseline nearest the Lead Official...As Team A player shoots the Team B player is still waving from below the waist to above the head. This is clearly a violation and the waving movement is the worst I have ever seen in a V game at any level..Team A misses the FT and Team B rebounds. Would you have called disconcerting the shooter in this situation if you were the Lead?...This player would have been the Lead's responsibility due to his position on the baseline but there were only the 3 Team B players on that table side with 2 opposite the table side...What would you do if you were the Trail and the Lead passed on it? I need some unbiased opinions please...Should the call have been made no matter the situation-score/playoff/loser goes home?... Should the kids "be allowed to settle things on the floor" and not by the Official's whistle?...I can tell you there have been 2 very wide schools of thought around here as to whether or not game Officials should have passed or made the call... After a few responses I will post what we did.
__________________
Cam Aulds 
|
|
Sun Mar 10, 2002, 08:48am
|
|||
|
|||
|
I guess the way I look at it is what would you do in the first quarter? I think it is bull for an official to make a different call in the last minute as opposed to the first minute. How can you say the official decided the play? I don't think the lead or trail was the one waving his arms during the free throw! I had the exact same call in the last minute of a game this year. It was a lane violation then and it was in your game. Team A gets another free throw no matter which official calls it. If my partner passed on this I would call it as a trail.
Keep 'em "straight up"
|
|
Sun Mar 10, 2002, 07:32pm
|
|||
|
|||
|
Had a kid standing behind the shooter outside the three line, was whistling and it was completely obvious he was trying to disconcert the shooter. I called and the kid looked at me like I was nuts. Told him he can't do that. It was also at the end of the game.
Also, as is always said the officials never decide the game, the players on the floor do. The official that says he doesn't want to make a call in the last minuet because he doesn't want to decide the game is now deciding the game for the kids by not calling something that was a violation or foul earlier in the game. If it was a foul or violation at the tip, it is a foul or violation as time expires.
__________________
"Contact does not mean a foul, a foul means contact." -Me
|
|
Sun Mar 10, 2002, 07:54pm
|
|||
|
|||
|
I have disconcertion.
|
|
Sun Mar 10, 2002, 10:15pm
|
|||
|
|||
Quote:
I have disconcertion and a quiet warning to the player for unsporting action. mick
|
|
Sun Mar 10, 2002, 11:04pm
|
|||
|
|||
|
OK...Here's what happened.
I was the trail on the FT shot...The Team B player continued to wave his arms repeatedly starting below his waist and ending above his head even after the Team A player was releasing the ball...It was the most extreme example of this violation I had ever seen at any level...As there were no other Team A players at the FT area, there was 3 team B players opposite me, table side...As the shot hit the rim the Team B players converged on the rebound...I put my fist out for the delayed call and waited for my partner to have a chance to get it (Mechanically it was his guy to get)...When he didn't blow it I stepped in and told him I had a violation...Instead my partner had awarded a T/O to Team B...Both teams headed to their bench. My partner hated the call...I explained the call to the Team B coach and told him there would be no T/O and there would be repeat of the second FT...Of course the kid hits the FT to give his team a 4 point lead...That was the final as team A didn't even defend the 3 point brick that B threw up. My partner felt that I did not allow the kids to settle the game on the court...I feel just the opposite...Just because a score is close in the last 2 minutes doesn't mean we should give both teams carte blanche to do whatever they want in the name of allowing them settle it on the floor. The next day's paper quoted the losing coach as saying he had never heard of such a rule...This was no surprise at all...Meanwhile, in subsequent days, my partner has been trashing me to any Official who would listen...Several of them have called me to tell me so...I was stunned by this turn of events...A coach not knowing the rules?...Very believable...My partner embelishing the truth and trashing me to other Officials?...Unconscionable!...Unfathomable! It is my considered opinion that if it was a foul/violation in the first period, it should be with 7.2 seconds left in the 4th as well...It is my considered theory that you Officiate the game until the end. Sadly, not everyone feels as I do...Thank you for your unbiased opinions...While 3 Officials who were looking on in the crowd supported the call and several have called to agree, they are still people I know and work games with...Were they just being a friend or did they really feel that way? Thank God for the eyewitnesses...I have told anyone who wants to, to ask for their opinion...They know the rules and have called the games...Ask them what really happened. I have gotten honest opinions from those who responded...You don't know me, haven't worked with me and have no reason to agree with me if you really don't feel that way...You can't know how much I have appreciated knowing others truly feel as I do and would have done as I did. In my heart I knew I did the right thing and given the same set of circumstances, would make the same call again.
__________________
Cam Aulds
|
|
Sun Mar 10, 2002, 11:12pm
|
|||
|
|||
|
The one thing I would suggest - blow your whistle!
If teams are in a TO huddle, then learn that there's no TO, they'll be pissed - especially because it looks like you and your partner got together to screw over team B. On the other hand, if you have a strong whistle after your partner's TO signal, it gives credibility that you had already "planned" to call the delayed violation.
__________________
"To win the game is great. To play the game is greater. But to love the game is the greatest of all."
|
|
Sun Mar 10, 2002, 11:12pm
|
|||
|
|||
|
Quote:
|
|
Mon Mar 11, 2002, 01:23am
|
|||
|
|||
|
Hang in there. In the long run he will tarnish his reputation and yours will weather this out. Don't bad mouth him but continue with the facts. do you have a good board on your association? I feel like I do and I would go to them with an issue like this, so it does not continue all summer and you can move on.
__________________
Ron
|
|
Mon Mar 11, 2002, 04:25am
|
|||
|
|||
|
To BktBallRef...I am not the "4th year Ref" on the McGriff board...I have never posted there...I started Officiating in Louisiana in 1976 and continued when I moved here to Michigan.
To Mark...I did blow my whistle...It was almost simultaneous with the lead's as he granted the T/O...I would have normally blown it quicker but given it was his guy to get I waited a split second to give him a chance to do that...When we sounded together, I thought he must have called the violation when in fact the player had told him before the first FT that they wanted a T/O after the last FT. You are right though...It would have helped matters if I had sounded my whistle immediately.
__________________
Cam Aulds
|
|
Mon Mar 11, 2002, 10:00am
|
|||
|
|||
Your partner sounds like one of those "veteran" officials who think that they can decide which rules they choose to enforce. This one team B clearly gains an advantage by disconcerting the thrower A. I would not worry about this guy you worked with. Anyone who wouldn't call this clear violation is an idiot. Keep up the good work and above all, be consistent in your calls. Most coaches feel that is the most important thing for us to do. Tight or loose as long as all the calls are the same on both ends of the floor.
Keep 'em "straight up"
|
|
Mon Mar 11, 2002, 10:20am
|
|||
|
|||
|
Quote:
[Edited by BktBallRef on Mar 12th, 2002 at 10:04 AM]
|
|
Mon Mar 11, 2002, 10:40am
|
|||
|
|||
|
"wasn't asking about you", TH, "wasn't"!! LOL
Chuck [Edited by ChuckElias on Mar 11th, 2002 at 09:45 AM]
|
 |
| Bookmarks |
|
|
Linear Mode
