![]() |
Quote:
Their either a team member or they aren't. Keep in mind I don't think that you cold ever consider the Varsity members affiliates or team members of the JV team. Edit...The key to knowing that the assistant is a team member is that he @ one time was on the bench. |
Here's where you're going to have trouble with this. JV game prior to the varsity game, varsity coach sits on the bench as an assistant during the first half. He spends the 2nd half with his varsity players. Just before the end of the 4th, the team is standing in the corner waiting for their turn, and you hear him make a comment like I mentioned above. You gonna T him now?
You gonna get him for leaving the bench area, too? |
Quote:
Again the KEY here is that he was on the bench which leaves no question that he is affiliated with the team. |
Good luck with that.
What if he makes no comments whatsoever, and you notice he's standing in the corner with the varsity guys? |
Quote:
This being rule supported since he in fact was on the bench in the first half, he is affiliated with the JV team. Not that its very likely/common for either of these to happen, dunk by varsity in JV game, unsporting comment by VHC back in the corner, but if they do the latter I can handle with a penalty and be confident that I'm backed by the rules. The former on the other hand isn't rule supported, IMO! |
This is the most ridicluous post I've ever viewed on this site. 127 replies!!!!!!!!!!! You folks have too much time on your hands, get out there and officiate!!! Discuss the issues that come up during the game.
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
day/week/season/whatever? And you mean to say that if one of the stars in the JV had 4 fouls you would.......oops, wrong thread. Never mind.:D |
Quote:
Good thing I made a New Year's resolution this year to not tell any of the posters here to piss off. Piss off. Damn, happens every year........:rolleyes: |
Quote:
|
Quote:
Although I am kind of suprised this thread is still being discussed. |
Quote:
Actually, being in the book is not what makes him a team member. Being in the book is not part of the definition of team member. If he gets left off the book, he can still be a team member, and have his name added, at the expense of a technical foul. So, continuing your line of reasoning, coach sends #23 into the game. Scorer announces there is no #23. You announce technical foul. Coach says, "Wait a minute. 23 wasn't even supposed to be dressed out for the JV game. He's not affiliated with this team. Let me send in somebody else." You say, "Fine, coach. He just can't sit on your bench any more." |
Eligible ???
If they're not in the scorebook (after the ten minute mark), and if they're not going to be put into the scorebook (before the ten minute mark), then, in my opinion, they're not eligible to participate, and they are not part of the junior varsity team.
|
From my perspective there are only three relevant points to this.
1) Dunking player is warming up with JV team. 2) Dunking player is in team uniform 3) Dunking player Dunked :D T |
Quote:
Ignats: I love your thinking. MTD, Sr. |
Quote:
|
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 05:53pm. |