NF Part II

[kbilla]

Originally Posted by Nevadaref

Don't read anything into the question that is not printed.

Ball is tapped to B2 who taps it up in the air and it is grabbed by B1 who was one of the jumpers...the ball never hit the floor and it is not a violation - I don't get what I am reading into the question? It must be something, but I'm not seeing it?

[Mregor]

Originally Posted by kbilla

Ball is tapped to B2 who taps it up in the air and it is grabbed by B1 who was one of the jumpers...the ball never hit the floor and it is not a violation - I don't get what I am reading into the question? It must be something, but I'm not seeing it?

The OP said nothing about it hitting the floor. It just asked a simple question. You are reading too many taps. Tapped ball, as in legally tapping the jump ball like both jumpers normally attempt to do, and jumper A1 catches it. It's not tapped to another player to again taps it and then A1 catches it. Where do you get B2? Once you get into the what if, you are reading into it. Answer the question as written - you'll consistently score higher.

[kbilla]

Originally Posted by Mregor

The OP said nothing about it hitting the floor. It just asked a simple question. You are reading too many taps. Tapped ball, as in legally tapping the jump ball like both jumpers normally attempt to do, and jumper A1 catches it. It's not tapped to another player to again taps it and then A1 catches it. Where do you get B2? Once you get into the what if, you are reading into it. Answer the question as written - you'll consistently score higher.

??? The OP specifically references the ball touching the floor! I understand what you are saying, all I am saying is that the real answer to the question is "not necessarily", it isn't T or F....I scored 96 and this is the only one of the four I didn't get that is questionable to me....the question states that it is T that it is a violation for a jumper to catch a tapped ball before it hits the floor...all I am saying is that it could be true, but it also could be false...just one of those questions I guess, I know they aren't always clear cut...

[Mregor]

Originally Posted by kbilla

??? The OP specifically references the ball touching the floor! I understand what you are saying, all I am saying is that the real answer to the question is "not necessarily", it isn't T or F....I scored 96 and this is the only one of the four I didn't get that is questionable to me....the question states that it is T that it is a violation for a jumper to catch a tapped ball before it hits the floor...all I am saying is that it could be true, but it also could be false...just one of those questions I guess, I know they aren't always clear cut...

My mistake, I meant hitting another player, your B2. The rest I stand behind. You are assuming other facts not presented. If they don't say it hit another player first, it didn't and you shouldn't assume it did or answer what if...

[Nevadaref]

The question states that the ball was tapped. Tapping is a touch by a jumper. Furthermore, since nothing else appears in the question that is the only action that has taken place. Nothing else has happended with the ball before one of the jumpers catches it.

You are reading other stuff into it, specifically you are saying what if the ball touches or was touched by another player. Since the question doesn't say that it was, then it wasn't.

Go with what the question says and that is that the ball was tapped. That's all.

[kbilla]

Thanks guys..I'm sure you're right, I am just a bit hard headed I guess.