The Official Forum

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)
-   Basketball (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/)
-   -   Flopping (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/39859-flopping.html)

Adam Mon Nov 26, 2007 04:10pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Snaqwells
Hey, I'm trying to be empathetic. You're not helping me with your ridicule.

Sorry, I misspelled "Thank you."

M&M Guy Mon Nov 26, 2007 04:14pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Snaqwells
Sorry, I misspelled "Thank you."

I understand. It must be that time of month.

Oops, now I've done it...

gordon30307 Mon Nov 26, 2007 04:27pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by M&M Guy
If it was outside my area, of course my partner probably had the better look.

You lied. Remember you have definite knowledge your partner missed it. (Incidentally, I'd do the same.) But you lied to the Coach. Now the Coach says "you'er a liar I know you saw it." Are you launching him? How do you justify launching him when he calls you on it? (I'm launching him)

I still have a question for you: what is your justification for making up a call (calling a block with no contact), and then lying to the coach about the call ("I saw it different")?

If I'm not mistaken I think Mark Twain said something like this. There's lies and their's damned lies. It was just a lie.

Have a good day.:D

Adam Mon Nov 26, 2007 04:33pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by gordon30307
If I'm not mistaken I think Mark Twain said something like this. There's lies and their's damned lies. It was just a lie.

Have a good day.:D

98% of us think you're making that up. :D

M&M Guy Mon Nov 26, 2007 04:37pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by gordon30307
You lied. Remember you have definite knowledge your partner missed it. (Incidentally, I'd do the same.) But you lied to the Coach. Now the Coach says "you'er a liar I know you saw it." Are you launching him? How do you justify launching him when he calls you on it? (I'm launching him)

How is it a lie to tell the coach your partner had a better look at it? :confused: I know what <B>I</B> saw, but I don't know what <B>my partner</B> saw, especially if it's in their area.

You also haven't answered my questions yet.

Adam Mon Nov 26, 2007 04:39pm

FWIW, if you had that good a look at it, you may as well just own up to the coach and say you missed it.

gordon30307 Mon Nov 26, 2007 05:46pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by M&M Guy
How is it a lie to tell the coach your partner had a better look at it? :confused: I know what <B>I</B> saw, but I don't know what <B>my partner</B> saw, especially if it's in their area.

It's a lie because your partner blew it and you know it. Better look, not my area no different then me saying maybe I missed it etc.

You also haven't answered my questions yet.

I'll answer it like this. I don't lie to my friends (partners) if you do it's a damned lie. Coaches aren't my friends so it's a lie.

If you tell me in 20 years of reffing you never ever, ever, ever:D lied to a Coach that's a damned lie.

gordon30307 Mon Nov 26, 2007 05:47pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Snaqwells
98% of us think you're making that up. :D

Touche'

just another ref Mon Nov 26, 2007 06:00pm

Why get the coach involved? Just look at the guy who flopped and say thank you.

JRutledge Mon Nov 26, 2007 06:08pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by M&M Guy
Jeff, I'm not talking about simply what a coach thinks. I'm also not talking about going over to the coach and telling them my partner screwed up. I'm talking about the credibility of an official that outright lies about their call. I'm talking about this situation. If one of my partners lies about a call, our whole crew has been affected. If I know he made up this call, how do I know he doesn't make up other calls? Should I start watching his area? How do I know he got the proper shooter for the FT, and not just picked out any player because he wasn't watching? Damn! I just missed a call because I'm too busy thinking about these things. The overall perfomance of the crew, and the trust level between crew members has come down a couple of notches.

I personally do not care whether a coach thinks I lied to them or not. I do not worry about what coaches ultimately think. They already think you lie and cheat, so what is another conversation going to do to change that opinion?

And if my partner sees something and I disagree with it, you damn right I am going to lie to save my partner. My partner is my friend, not a coach. Coaches will sell you out all the time even when you are completely honest with them.

Stop worrying about credibility that you have with coaches. If you lose credibility just because of one conversation the coach is worry too much about you and not their team.

JMO.

Peace

M&M Guy Mon Nov 26, 2007 06:27pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by gordon30307
It's a lie because your partner blew it and you know it. Better look, not my area

You're making a big assumption that I know for sure my partner blew a call. I may have a pretty good idea, but I'm not going to lie to a coach. I may tell the coach I'll try to get an explanation from my partner at the next opportunity. I may, in rare instances, go to my partner and give them information that might help them change their call.

Quote:

Originally Posted by gordon30307
If you tell me in 20 years of reffing you never ever, ever, ever lied to a Coach that's a damned lie.

I've done plenty of things wrong in 20 years. And I'll probably do a few things wrong before this week is done. I'm constantly working on trying to get things right.

But I guess I'm not following your logic. What does that have to do with <B>purposely</B> calling a foul with no contact? I'm waiting to hear your justification for doing that, and then lying to the coach about why you made that particular call.

M&M Guy Mon Nov 26, 2007 06:31pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by JRutledge
Stop worrying about credibility that you have with coaches.

I'm talking about the credibility of your partner. If you're doing the right thing, who cares what other people think? But can you work with, and trust, a partner who makes up calls?

JRutledge Mon Nov 26, 2007 06:44pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by M&M Guy
I'm talking about the credibility of your partner. If you're doing the right thing, who cares what other people think? But can you work with, and trust, a partner who makes up calls?

I am going to trust them for that night. After that is a different situation. But that has nothing to do with what we are talking about right now.

Look on most nights I am working with different people on a regular basis. I do not always work with the same guys as you might be able to. And because of that I can work with people of all levels. I am not going to sweat the small stuff that often, because if I did I would really drive myself crazy.

Peace

Ref_in_Alberta Tue Nov 27, 2007 12:31pm

I've never "T'd" a player for flopping... however this is the way I deal with it...

1. I'll tell the player in no uncretain terms to get up

2a. Any marginal contact by this player (by flopping); most likely will be a foul so that...

2b. At the 1st chance to educate the player as to the penalty for flopping.

3. If the behavior continues at this point, when the oppurtunity allows itself I'll go to the coach and say "Coach, I need your help with number ___, In my view he (or she) is continuing to fake being fouled (flopping) after I have warned them, I would like you to address this before I have to. Thank you"

4. By this point, it should be dealt with however there is no question if there is a "T" for flopping, it will not be a surprise to anyone...

My 2 cents

mbyron Tue Nov 27, 2007 02:09pm

So first you warn the player, then you really warn him, then you warn his coach that you warned him. Do you have any rules backup for all those warnings?

Flopping is an unsporting T. Why not avail yourself of the rulebook penalty?


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 08:22pm.



Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.3.0 RC1