Rule Relapse - Please Help

[Jurassic Referee]

Originally Posted by GarthB

You have confused the fact that everyone is equal in their right to have an opinion with the myth that all opinions are equal. They are not.

When there is a definitive ruling in the rule book, then any opinion going against that ruling is an incorrect opinion imo. Note that I'm not giving my own feeling as to what the correct call might turn out to be. I'm going by the strict wording of the rule book now. And Mr. Webb admits himself that the strict wording of the rule book has to be clarified to fit his opinion.