So, what is 9.2.2 SITUATION C?

I have followed this discussion from the beginning. I do not think you can go back and correct a missed violation.

Consider this play. A1 drives and does a jump stop in the Trail's primary area. A1 then pivots, then shoots a jump shot that is good. The Trail lets the play go. The Lead is focus on players in his primary and does not see the play. Coach B calls a time out after the made basket and wants to discuss the "violation." Trail admits a jump stop occurred and then a pivot and says it is legal. Coach B now appeals to you. Trail does not know the rule. You know the rule. Do you wipe out a basket on a play that was never whistled? I don't. I tell the coach we can discuss this play after the game if he wants, but as a crew, we live with it and take the heat.

I am still awaiting the interpretation of Mr. Jenkins.

Uhmmm...why would a jump stop followed by a pivot be a violation? That move has been around since Earl the Pearl Monroe made it poplular back in the 50's...a jumpstop does not establish a pivot foot, so they can still pivot on one of those feets of theirs without travelling...

I can NOT believe I actually added to the length of this thread!!:mad:

Kinda like quicksand, isn't it? Get too close, and it sucks you right in.

More like a potato chip...take that first one out of the bag & before you know it you're scraping the greasy crumbs from the bottom...speaking of scraping crumbs, how is it that Chuck has completely ignored this thread??

What most of us refer to as a jump stop is what is described in 4-44-2-a-3 and 4-44-2-b-2.

In both of these cases, neither foot can be a pivot.

This is nothing more than calling a violation and waving off a basket, no different than saying A1 goes in for a spectacular dunk, but travels on the way up. Ruling: call the violation and wave off the basket

Cool! You're starting to get it now!

:)

I disagree.<i></i>

What?!

I wasn't aware of that.

What was the question again?

....here, have a potato chip

Starting to get what? I don't get it.

Omg!!!
 

Thirteen pages over this topic? :rolleyes:

Peace

Oh, don't worry. We're still a long way from the off-topic thread record.

(Btw, don't remind me what that thread was about. :( )

You had it right earlier:
Mabe I had it wrong in calling it a correctable error. Even I had a problem trying to convince myself of correcting this even withing the correctable error time limits. But this case play makes more sense. A violation occured, the basket happened (relatively) immediately afterwards, we acknowledge the violation happened, wipe off the basket, and go on.