foul out and free throws with a T

[zebraman]

Originally Posted by Jurassic Referee

Whoa there, Bunky......

What do you mean "everyone else"?

I didn't agree with Chuck's view. Still don't. Not that it really matter though. If the official FED view is different than my personal view, the FED wins....every time.

Easy there grumpy.

I didn't mean that you agreed with the ruling, I meant that you agreed that the Fed had ruled on this issue as to NOT be a correctable error. Now if I could only remember what the original issue was.

Z

[Jurassic Referee]

Originally Posted by zebraman

Easy there grumpy.

I didn't mean that you agreed with the ruling, I meant that you agreed that the Fed had ruled on this issue as to NOT be a correctable error. Now if I could only remember what the original issue was.

Z

Grumpy? Moi?

I agreed that Bob J. supplied a FED ruling that stated that my opinion was wrong. That FED ruling is now definitive as far as I'm concerned. Iow, as stated before, I was wrong. Now we have a conflicting Illinois ruling. Well, that rule is now a definitive ruling in Illinois imo. That doesn't mean that it's also a definitive ruling in the other 49 states. And that is unfortunate, and that is why we need something new out of the FED that will apply everywhere. It's not a matter really of any official here being right or wrong; it's a matter of getting a ruling that we all can use uniformly.

Make sense, Z?

[JRutledge]

Originally Posted by Jurassic Referee

That doesn't mean that it's also a definitive ruling in the other 49 states. And that is unfortunate, and that is why we need something new out of the FED that will apply everywhere. It's not a matter really of any official here being right or wrong; it's a matter of getting a ruling that we all can use uniformly.

Unless all interpreters read rulings posted here or hold on to several year old rulings, then all 50 states are not going to be on the same page. We cannot get different officials in different areas in my state to always agree. If the NF feels strongly about this ruling, they should update their books to support it. I have yet to receive this year's rulebook. Who knows maybe this will be covered in a clearer manner.

Peace

[Jurassic Referee]

Originally Posted by JRutledge

I have yet to receive this year's rulebook. Who knows maybe this will be covered in a clearer manner.

I've got my new books. Nothing has changed with regards to this one.