wait just a minute now.....

[tweetz]

(from JTRICE)
-----------------------------------------------------------
Held ball.
Possession arrow is pointing toward Team A's basket.
Official hands the ball to A1 for the throw-in.
B1 reaches across the end-line as he is trying to defend the throw-in.
Official blows whistle and warns Team B for crossing the vertical plane on the throw-in. The warning is recorded in the score book.
Official starts the throw-in again.
Throw-in is completed.

Official does NOT change the Possession arrow.
Is the official correct
------------------------------------------------------------

the arrow should have been changed as soon as the ball was at the disposal of the inbounder... shouldn't it?

[FishinRef]

The arrow is changed when ANY player inbounds touches the ball to constitute a "Live Ball".

[jritchie]

yes official is correct...rule 9-2-11, it is now a violation instead of Alt. poss throw in

[FishinRef]

Held ball.
Possession arrow is pointing toward Team A's basket.
Official hands the ball to A1 for the throw-in.
B1 reaches across the end-line as he is trying to defend the throw-in.
Official blows whistle and warns Team B for crossing the vertical plane on the throw-in. The warning is recorded in the score book.
Official starts the throw-in again.
Throw-in is completed.

Official does NOT change the Possession arrow.
Is the official correct

The throw-in Violation by B has NO affect on the AP arrow. After the violation is recorded in the book, the A team’s AP throw-in is COMPLETED. As soon as the the throw in is COMPLETED the AP arrow goes to Team B.

[Mark T. DeNucci, Sr.]

Originally posted by FishinRef
Held ball.
Possession arrow is pointing toward Team A's basket.
Official hands the ball to A1 for the throw-in.
B1 reaches across the end-line as he is trying to defend the throw-in.
Official blows whistle and warns Team B for crossing the vertical plane on the throw-in. The warning is recorded in the score book.
Official starts the throw-in again.
Throw-in is completed.

Official does NOT change the Possession arrow.
Is the official correct

The throw-in Violation by B has NO affect on the AP arrow. After the violation is recorded in the book, the A team’s AP throw-in is COMPLETED. As soon as the the throw in is COMPLETED the AP arrow goes to Team B.

FishinRef:

The official was correct in not reversing the AP Arrow. When B1 reached through the plane he committed a throw-in violation; See NFHS R9-S2-A11. Since in this play Team B had not previously received an official team warning, the penalty for B1's violation is that a team warning is issued to Team B and Team A receives a throw-in. This new throw-in is not an AP Throw-in but is part of the penalty for B1's violation. The AP Arrow is not reversed because Team A's AP Throw-in never ended because of B1's violation; see NFHS R4-S42-A5 for the definition of when a throw-in ends.

The next time a jump ball situation occurs, Team A will receive the ball for a AP Throw-in.

MTD, Sr.

[ChuckElias]

Originally posted by tweetz
the arrow should have been changed as soon as the ball was at the disposal of the inbounder... shouldn't it?

Nope, tweetz. The AP arrow is switched when the AP throw-in is complete (is touched by a player inbounds or OOB) or when a throw-in violation is committed.

So if we have an AP throw-in, and A1 has the ball OOB for the throw-in, the arrow is NOT changed if a foul is committed (by either team) before the throw-in is complete. The arrow is also NOT changed if a violation is committed by the defense. The arrow IS changed if a throw-in violation is committed by the inbounding team.

[ChuckElias]

Originally posted by FishinRef
The arrow is changed when ANY player inbounds touches the ball to constitute a "Live Ball".

Any player, other than the thrower-in, inbounds or out of bounds. And remember that the ball becomes live when it is handed to the inbounder; not when when it is touched inbounds.

[archer]

By rule when does the arrow change on a throw in?

[ChuckElias]

Originally posted by archer
By rule when does the arrow change on a throw in?

Archer, I wrote this just two posts above yours

"The AP arrow is switched when the AP throw-in is complete (is touched by a player inbounds or OOB) or when a throw-in violation is committed."

Hope it's clearer this time.

[archer]

Sorry Chuck didnt see your post.

[FishinRef]

Mark & Chuck, after some serious investigation into my rule book, I now understand your interpretation on this scenario. I stand corrected, thanks for the lesson.

[ChuckElias]

Originally posted by archer
Sorry Chuck didnt see your post.

No sweat. That's what copy and paste are for

[Time2Ref]

Now I'm really confused.

Isn't there another thread just like this one? Just when I thought I learned something, I find a new thread with a different answer.

Chuck Elias, I read you definition of when an A.P. throw-in is complete. What is that part in the parenthesis? Is that part of the rule or a part that you added? Could you please site the rule so that I can look it up in the book?

Could this be a difference between NFHS and NCAA rules?

thanks.

[Back In The Saddle]

Via the aforementioned miracle of copy and paste, here you go, Time2Ref:

"The direction of the possession arrow is reversed immediately after an alternating-possession throw-in ends. An alternating-possession throw-in ends when the throw-in ends or when the throw-in team violates." (NFHS 6-4-4)

"The throw-in ends when the passed ball touches, or is touched by, an inbounds player other than the thrower." (NFHS 4-42-5)

[Time2Ref]

That's the rule I've been looking for. (NFHS 4.42.5)

Thanks.

(Yea! I did learn something)

Please accept my humble appology for wasting forum space.