|
Not on my whistle.
|
Quote:
Sure about that? It has to be a travel or a palm. |
Yup, the official called it. That makes it a done deal. Judgement call.
Looked to me like he nailed it too. |
Quote:
Nailed- Got it wrong, or Nailed- Got it right? |
Right, Brandan.
|
B, if you're hitting a nail with a hammer and you "nail" it, does that mean you missed the nail?
|
The more obvious carry was right after the steal up against the sideline.
|
Quote:
Hmmmm... Idk.... I didnt look at it that way. :-p |
Quote:
|
Perhaps we should have a distinction:
By rule, is it plaming? If, by rule, it's palming, would you call it? |
Quote:
In the open court with no defender, it needs to be A LOT more blatant, than this dribble was, for me to call it. |
Quote:
[Edited by BktBallRef on Feb 12th, 2005 at 01:55 PM] |
Quote:
Also in the slo-mo, it did look like a palming violation to me. I think that the defender being tricked by the play may have had an impact on the official's ruling. |
If you look closely you can see the ball resting in his palm as he brings it behind his back. That ends the dribble. I've got a carry or double dribble, it could have been called either way. Good call by the officials, I didn't catch it until the close up, but that official got it right. If you ever read this forum, good job man, that was a great call. :)
Mike, as 4-43-3-c "After establishing a pivot foot, the pivot foot bay not be lifted before the ball is released, to start a dribble" So when the next dribble was released before the pivot foot returned to the floor it would be a travel. The next dribble has to be released before the pivot foot leaves the floor. So there's 3 things that could've been called here, travel, illegal dribble, or carrying. Mike, here's something you'd probably find funny, as I was leaving the gym after doing my morning games, I get cut off by this black car, now I'm swearing at the guy, when I look at his license plate "AL 54" :D:D:D:D [Edited by ref18 on Feb 12th, 2005 at 02:24 PM] |
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:50pm. |