Changing your partner's call

[ChuckElias]

Originally posted by Jurassic Referee
What happens if I don't think that I actually did miss the call, but I had it right?

The fact is, tho, that you didn't have it right. Otherwise your partner wouldn't have blown the whistle.

What you are actually saying here is that your judgement is better than mine.

Nah. I'm saying my view was better on that one play in that gray area. I'll still work with you tomorrow night.

I may wanna disagree with that.

Then you'd be wrong twice. The premise of this procedure is that you missed the call and it's obvious to your partner. If you accept that premise (viz., this will only happen when you inadvertantly make an obvious error), then I don't see the problem.