Can't be the first one to touch it?

[Nu1]

One thing to think about...can the player dribble or not?

NFHS Case Book, under Rule 7;
If A1 tips a ball before going OOB, he/she can return inbounds, secure the ball AND dribble.

If A1 controls the ball before going OOB (i.e. grabs it and throws it inbounds before falling OOB), he/she can return inbounds and secure the ball BUT CANNOT dribble.

This situation is confused a lot! Being a new official, I have friends and coaches who ask, "What about..." This has been one of those subjects. Unfortunately, officials often have differing opinions on this, even though the rules book and case book - for NFHS - seem to make it clear.