|
Typical response from most officials, too big of an ego to admit mistakes. This call was a huge mistake, and if you do not understand why, you need to get in touch with some refs who have to the big time and ask why.
I can give you an example of a play that never gets called at the end of a game becuase it is not affecting the play. Oone second left and team a has an inbounds at opposite end of floor and needs a basket to tie or win. It is a throw in after a made basket so they can run the baseline.they set up in one corner and run towards the other end, all the while a screen is set inbounds where the person guarding the throw in player will run over them as they move with the passer. I have seen this trick used many times in big mens tournamnets game, and guess what, even if the payler flats runs over the screener nothing is ever called. Some refs understand the sprit of the rules is the important thing not the technical side. the ref in the Baylor game had every right to call this foul per the rules as they are written, but he never should have.There is no way tenn player had time 10 ft from the basket with her back towards it, to tip it in. It was scramble for a loose ball and you could even make a case for the foul should not have been called period even with 5 mins left. One other point did anybody see if the bu player had established herself inbounds before she touches the ball? That would have made a difference in the call. We have all made erros and the official in this case and the ncaa should admit one. We are far from perfect. |
Dexter
You said.. "As to why it matters more with 0.2 left on the clock in a tied regional semi-final game . . . figure that one out yourself." Are you sayin that it is treated "differently" based on the situation ?? Seems that you may be. BTW.. I read your posts.. and you make some nice points. Just question this one. |
And why on earth are they not using precision time ?? I don't watch women's college too much.. just curious.
|
Is the post above by Judge an April Fools joke? Seriously?
Or just something posted from an April fool? |
Quote:
I will admit that I've seen similar situations where there was no call. And I've seen calls made. This call didn't bother me. |
Quote:
My guess is by being a new poster, Judge probably lost a few skins in Vegas on this game. |
Quote:
|
You know.. I was thinking that maybe Precision Time wasn't being used... cuz I noticed a lot of the guys.. chopping the clock from the stop-clock position... with hand nowhere near the timing device. I guess I was assuming that maybe they had pregamed that a non-administering official would start the timing device.
Anyhow... Anyone know why they don't use Precision Time in the tournament ??? If in fact they don't. |
They have been having trouble with the equipment at the Lloyd Noble Center for a long time. The clock stops when the whistle is blown (they finally got that one fixed), but they have never been able to use the belt packs to start the clock with any reliability. So they're just chopping in, and it seems to be a much better solution. I'm surprised that the NCAA would let us host a regional unless all the equipment was working properly. (But maybe the NCAA didn't know?) And I don't know enough about the equipment to understand why they couldn't get the technical problems fixed before the tourney. Or before the start of the regular season, for that matter.
|
THE BIG EAST vs acc
Quote:
|
the foul was called...fine. When you go to the monitor...do you check for the whistle? Since the whistle stops the clock...I don't think they did. Marcy Weston's statement claimed they checked for the whistle, which I think is impossible here. Impact occurred at .2 seconds remaining. They should have gone OT.
|
Or were they checking to see if the official's arm went up before the horn sounded? Since we are talking about signals here, then there must be a time lag between the time the whistle is blown and the time the clock actually stops ... miniscule perhaps, but still a lag. Does the equipment adjust for the lag, or is it up to the officiating crew (table people included) to make that adjustment?
In any case, the NCAA is going to review the whole thing when they have their meeting in New Orleans this weekend. And I assume that they will publish an explanation. Sure hope so! I still think that it was a good call, however unfortunate and nerve-racking it may have been to all of us who were having fun watching David stick it to Goliath. Kind of reminds me of the movie where Billy Crystal makes a call in the final seconds of an NBA game and the home crowd is ready to lynch him. The fan boards are buzzing with all kinds of crazy stuff. My favorite one is : 'ESPN will do anything to make sure that they have a UConn/Tennessee matchup in the final game.' |
Confirmed Judge is a FANBOY
I was just looking around to see some reaction at Baylor and I clicked on a message board and found a very interesting post.
It is as follows from http://www.baylorfans.com/forums/showthread.php?t=54111 This is a just a portion of the post....... Apparently the NCAA knows that (some of, when it is in their favor) its own rules exist. Do their officials? It does not appear to be so. Every media report that I have seen, including the Knoxville News (http://www.knoxnews.com/kns/gv_colu...2768406,00.html) and Yahoo (www.sports.yahoo.com) (so it is not just ESPN) say that the officials reviewed the monitor to determine if the foul was committed during game play some (so lets give the benefit of a doubt) say it was to determine if the whistle was blown during the game........ The person's user name is Tree G. It is good to know that he doesn't have a vested interest in the game and was just posting here as a person who has "been an official for 24 years" |
No Precision Time for NCAA tourneys...
Quote:
|
Permit me to go off the subject a bit...That game prevented Stanford from going to the Final Four?? Stanford would have beaten Baylor??
|
| All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:51am. |