Quote:
Originally Posted by JRutledge
What is incorrect? It was BI. If he had grabbed the rim and then tried to put the ball in the hole, I would agree with a T if no violation was called. But the violation clearly took place and I see nothing that suggest that this is a BI and a T in this specific play. There are plays you could call both, but not in this play unless you just want to prove you know the rule and be overly "technical."
I also did not say anything about the rule differences either. I would rule it the same way in both, but not relevant to my position. If there was a rebound and the player grabbed the rim and then tried to but the ball in the basket, then I would agree. That is not really what happened here. A violation was called and basically ended the play. I do not expect you to agree, but that is what I am doing.
Peace
|
He actually did tap the rebound to put it back in....they didn't blow the whistle until that happened.
Accusing someone of being overly technical as a smokescreen to not not knowing the rules is pretty sad.
Tue Mar 21, 2017, 04:44pm
Similar Threads
Threaded Mode
