The Official Forum

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)
-   Basketball (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/)
-   -   Pre game technical (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/101692-pre-game-technical.html)

bob jenkins Wed Nov 30, 2016 08:17am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ed Maeder (Post 993818)
Did we forget to charge the bench personnel who dunked the ball with a direct tech. 1 of their 2 towards DQ, 1 of their 5 towards DQ, and 1 towards team total for bonus.

Plus indirect on coach.

But, my guess is that SeanFitz was asking about the double-T aspect

SeanFitzRef Wed Nov 30, 2016 04:21pm

OK, so we assessed the techs to each player, towards their count and the team count.
The confusion was around possession (none had been established), but in theory of the rule as applied, B gets 2 shots and possession, but then A gets 2 shots and the possession. (Assessed in order of occurence
B gets the next arrow, A starts with possession.

We forgot the indirect on the coaches.

Ed Maeder Wed Nov 30, 2016 04:30pm

Depends on order of occurrence. The last team to shoot the tech free throws would get the ball at the division line opposite, and when the thrower in received the ball the arrow would be set to the opposing team.

SeanFitzRef Wed Nov 30, 2016 04:45pm

Full disclosure of the situation:

A1 dunks 2 mins after we enter the court and give the obligatory whistle blast.
As I am standing with BOTH coaches confirming rosters, B2 dunks. This happened ` 2mins after the first and his head coach screamed the warning (again).

So, we marked the book as pf1 on both players, as well as 1 foul each towards the bonus. We then shot 2 throws for B (A's tech was first), 2 for A, then jumped center and went. (college mechanic)

Nothing in the case plays, and I know what happens after one. So it should have followed that the actions are penalized in the order of occurrence.

Again, we missed the biggest piece (indirect on the coaches, loss of coach box).

Live and learn long enough, you'll see it all.

SeanFitzRef Wed Nov 30, 2016 04:47pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ed Maeder (Post 993873)
Depends on order of occurrence. The last team to shoot the tech free throws would get the ball at the division line opposite, and when the thrower in received the ball the arrow would be set to the opposing team.

Yup, when we talked post game, that was the prevailing thought.

Nevadaref Thu Dec 01, 2016 04:28am

Quote:

Originally Posted by SeanFitzRef (Post 993879)
Full disclosure of the situation:

A1 dunks 2 mins after we enter the court and give the obligatory whistle blast.
As I am standing with BOTH coaches confirming rosters, B2 dunks. This happened ` 2mins after the first and his head coach screamed the warning (again).

So, we marked the book as pf1 on both players, as well as 1 foul each towards the bonus. We then shot 2 throws for B (A's tech was first), 2 for A, then jumped center and went. (college mechanic)

Nothing in the case plays, and I know what happens after one. So it should have followed that the actions are penalized in the order of occurrence.

Again, we missed the biggest piece (indirect on the coaches, loss of coach box).

Live and learn long enough, you'll see it all.

A couple of years ago the NFHS put out a ruling for pregame Ts by both teams and stated that they are treated as simultaneous fouls. Perhaps that was only for administrative technical fouls though. I will need to check.
It was a confusing ruling and not based upon the text of the rules book, but the NFHS did publish it.

junruh07 Thu Dec 01, 2016 10:22am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nevadaref (Post 993918)
A couple of years ago the NFHS put out a ruling for pregame Ts by both teams and stated that they are treated as simultaneous fouls. Perhaps that was only for administrative technical fouls though. I will need to check.
It was a confusing ruling and not based upon the text of the rules book, but the NFHS did publish it.

That was only for administrative Ts, such as one team adding a player to the roster at 8 min., and the other team changing a starter at 2 min. Pregame dunks by both teams are still treated as False Double Fouls.

BigCat Sat Dec 03, 2016 01:31pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nevadaref (Post 993918)
A couple of years ago the NFHS put out a ruling for pregame Ts by both teams and stated that they are treated as simultaneous fouls. Perhaps that was only for administrative technical fouls though. I will need to check.
It was a confusing ruling and not based upon the text of the rules book, but the NFHS did publish it.

3.4.3(c)

Welpe Sat Dec 03, 2016 11:12pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by BigCat (Post 994117)
3.4.3(c)


Starter, A1, has brought the wrong uniform and with eight minutes on the clock prior to the start of the game, switches with A15 and now is wearing a legal jersey but a new number. With two minutes on the clock prior to the start of the game, it is discovered that starter, B1, is wearing a different jersey than indicated in the scorebook. It is confirmed that a wrong number was provided to the official scorer and a change is made to reflect the correct number in the scorebook.

RULING: Both Team A and B are charged with a technical foul for changing a number in the scorebook and will begin the game with one team foul toward the bonus. No free throws are awarded and the game will begin at the point of interruption, which is the opening jump ball.

COMMENT: When each team is assessed one technical foul prior to the game, a double technical foul has occurred, as this is considered “approximately the same time.” (4-19-8b; 4-36-2c; 10-1-2) (See 6.4.1 SITUATION A)

Interesting reasoning. Especially when you go to the referenced case play.

6.4.1 Situation A:

"Twelve minutes before the game is scheduled to start, team member A1 dunks the ball and is charged with a technical foul. B1 is discovered to be wearing an illegal jersey, as the players prepare for the start of the game.

RULING: The game will be started by awarding Team B two free throws for A1’s technical foul. Team A will then be given two free throws and the ball for a division-line throw-in for B1’s infraction. When the thrower of Team A has the ball for the throw-in, they have control for purposes of establishing the alternating possession procedure and the arrow is immediately set toward B’s basket. Team B will have the first opportunity for an alternating-possession throw-in. (4-3)"

Confused yet?

Nevadaref Sun Dec 04, 2016 03:52am

Quote:

Originally Posted by junruh07 (Post 993927)
That was only for administrative Ts, such as one team adding a player to the roster at 8 min., and the other team changing a starter at 2 min. Pregame dunks by both teams are still treated as False Double Fouls.

The comment published with the case play does not specify that the ruling only applies to administrative technicals.

BigCat Sun Dec 04, 2016 04:45am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Welpe (Post 994133)
Starter, A1, has brought the wrong uniform and with eight minutes on the clock prior to the start of the game, switches with A15 and now is wearing a legal jersey but a new number. With two minutes on the clock prior to the start of the game, it is discovered that starter, B1, is wearing a different jersey than indicated in the scorebook. It is confirmed that a wrong number was provided to the official scorer and a change is made to reflect the correct number in the scorebook.

RULING: Both Team A and B are charged with a technical foul for changing a number in the scorebook and will begin the game with one team foul toward the bonus. No free throws are awarded and the game will begin at the point of interruption, which is the opening jump ball.

COMMENT: When each team is assessed one technical foul prior to the game, a double technical foul has occurred, as this is considered “approximately the same time.” (4-19-8b; 4-36-2c; 10-1-2) (See 6.4.1 SITUATION A)

Interesting reasoning. Especially when you go to the referenced case play.

6.4.1 Situation A:

"Twelve minutes before the game is scheduled to start, team member A1 dunks the ball and is charged with a technical foul. B1 is discovered to be wearing an illegal jersey, as the players prepare for the start of the game.

RULING: The game will be started by awarding Team B two free throws for A1’s technical foul. Team A will then be given two free throws and the ball for a division-line throw-in for B1’s infraction. When the thrower of Team A has the ball for the throw-in, they have control for purposes of establishing the alternating possession procedure and the arrow is immediately set toward B’s basket. Team B will have the first opportunity for an alternating-possession throw-in. (4-3)"

Confused yet?

We need to think harder about the words used.

When a player dunks, that T is charged to him and indirectly to coach(during pregame) . That is more than a T charged to a team. It is more than a team T.Administrative Ts only go to the TEAM. If there are techs before game that are only charged to TEAM as opposed to individuals those will offset.


S the words used have specific meanings

Nevadaref Sun Dec 04, 2016 05:13am

Quote:

Originally Posted by BigCat (Post 994135)
We need to think harder about the words used.

When a player dunks, that T is charged to him and indirectly to coach(during pregame) . That is more than a T charged to a team. It is more than a team T.Administrative Ts only go to the TEAM. If there are techs before game that are only charged to TEAM as opposed to individuals those will offset.


S the words used have specific meanings

I can go along with that reasoning.

SeanFitzRef Sun Dec 04, 2016 10:10pm

2016-17 case book. 6.4.1 situation F. Addresses my exact situation exactly.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 04:18am.



Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.3.0 RC1