BoomerSooner |
Thu Mar 24, 2016 12:47pm |
My initial thought while watching the video the first time was that the question was if there should have been a TC foul against Yale as it looked like the Yale player had extended his left arm into the Duke player to create space. I'm not sure I would have called anything, but that is what I thought I was supposed to be looking at based on the question and the video.
After watching the entire video and realizing what call was made and what the question actually was in the OP, I re-watched the video and am not of the belief that black had gained possession when the call was made. For that reason, I'm with those that would have considered this a TC foul against Duke. I also realize that if I originally thought the Yale player had stolen the ball and then pushed the Duke player when I first watched the video that it is possible the game official considered the Yale player to have possession.
I guess as far as learning something from this, my thought is that sometimes plays aren't black and white and that is why we still need experienced officials to make judgement calls like this. If we grant other officials the benefit of the doubt on the judgement aspect of calls (and remember they don't get to watch it 3 or 4 times like I did), I think we'll realize that they are going to apply the rules correctly almost without fail at this level. We can also disagree with and discuss the judgement aspect of the call as well, but if that is the context of the discussion, I don't think it is fair to criticize the application of the rules (in this case the awarding of FTs) without acknowledging that the actual game official may have assessed the play differently.
I'd point out that the uncertainty about when/if possession changed in this case makes using this video for Nevada's purpose of stressing that loose ball fouls by A are still TC fouls a bit of a challenge. If you are decidedly in the camp that Yale had not gained possession, then it is a good example to make his point. Otherwise, I bet you find more debate about the issue of possession than discussion on TC fouls.
|