Replay Review / Double Play!?

[Rich Ives]

Originally Posted by cmcramer

What about this rule text? Seems like it means NO double play?!

"No runner may be declared out by the Replay Official if no play was attempted on, or call made regarding, that runner (e.g., umpire cannot assume that a fielder would have thrown a runner out)."

My $0.02

There was already a clean throw to 1B which would have doubled off R1 if the correct call had been made. Don't need to assume a good throw. Already proven.

And the base R1 would have reached with a correct call is: none - he was dead meat.

So to me the option is there for a DP

[DG]

Originally Posted by Rich Ives

My $0.02

There was already a clean throw to 1B which would have doubled off R1 if the correct call had been made. Don't need to assume a good throw. Already proven.

And the base R1 would have reached with a correct call is: none - he was dead meat.

So to me the option is there for a DP

agreed