contradicting or not

[rcaverly]

Originally Posted by zebra2955

Rule 2 -5-art 1 –b A fair ball is a batted ball which: b, contacts fair ground on or beyond an imaginary line between first and third base…

Like others have said, once judged fair, it cannot change to foul.

Originally Posted by zebra2955

Rule 2-16-art 1 a A foul ball is a batted ball: a which settles on foul territory between home and first base or between home and third base..

This is ruling on a batted ball that has not yet been ruled fair, like in the first quote, above.

Originally Posted by zebra2955

Batter hits a ball with back spin which first hits beyond this imaginary line between first and third, spins back and settles in foul territory. By rule you could call it both ways or am I missing something here.

It may be possible to call it both ways, but not legally. The instant a batted ball touches anything or anybody on or over “the imaginary line,” it is legally a fair ball regardless of where it rolls.

[jicecone]

Originally Posted by rcaverly

Like others have said, once judged fair, it cannot change to foul. It may be possible to call it both ways, but not legally. The instant a batted ball touches anything or anybody on or over “the imaginary line,” it is legally a fair ball regardless of where it rolls.

Regardless of my opinion of this rule, you are absolutely correct