The Official Forum - MLB Rules Quiz and article

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)

- Baseball (https://forum.officiating.com/baseball/)

- - MLB Rules Quiz and article (https://forum.officiating.com/baseball/95296-mlb-rules-quiz-article.html)

if it's not the last inning, then "play" (or "the game") is still going on. R1 and R2 will advance on a walk. If for some reason, they don't, then, yes, get an out on appeal and cancel the run.

If it's the last inning, then R1 and R2 "don't mean anything", so under OBR (and NCAA, but not under FED), there's no need for them to advance (on a walk) to have the winning run score.

Quote:

Originally Posted by DavidOhsie (Post 897843)

OK, now I'm more confused :).

I understand that the rule only talks about the last inning, but is that the only time it applies? So if there is a 2-out bases loaded walk in the bottom of the first where R1 and R2 fail to advance, then the run doesn't score (if there is an appeal), but if the same happens in the bottom of the ninth, then the run does score (if there is an appeal)?

The rule you referenced is an exception to the norm due to the inning ending before it normally would (which can only happen in the home at bat of a final inning)... So yes, the exception can only apply in the home half of a final inning.

Can you imagine it ever actually happening that a 2-out bases loaded walk in any other situation would result in the runner from 1st or 2nd leaving the field? No - they go to their bases and we keep playing. Why would they leave?

Quote:

Originally Posted by bob jenkins (Post 897845)

Quote:

Originally Posted by MD Longhorn (Post 897848)

Makes perfect sense. Last question: why is a 7.05(a) homerun ("that goes out of the playing field") different? (If there is a reason).

Quote:

Originally Posted by DavidOhsie (Post 897855)

Makes perfect sense. Last question: why is a 7.05(a) homerun ("that goes out of the playing field") different? (If there is a reason).

It depends on what is meant by "or any other play" in 4.09(b)

Some would say that a home run qualifies and that as long as R3 and BR advance, the game is over.

Others (see Rich in post 10) say only a "non-batted ball award" can meet that definition and that the R1 and R2 must advance and touch.

Most of these are pretty simple stuff.
Question #5 states "makes a leaping catch and falls into the stands, holding on to the ball..."
I think maybe someone should clarify what is meant by the phrase "into the stands" (same wording as in rule 7.04c).

Quote:

Originally Posted by DavidOhsie (Post 897855)

Makes perfect sense. Last question: why is a 7.05(a) homerun ("that goes out of the playing field") different? (If there is a reason).

Game ending home runs are treated differently than all other walk-offs. Here's 4.11(c):
If the home team scores the winning run in its half of the ninth inning (or its half of an extra inning after a tie), the game ends immediately when the winning run is scored. EXCEPTION: If the last batter in a game hits a home run out of the playing field, the batter-runner and all runners on base are permitted to score, in accordance with the base-running rules, and the game ends when the batter-runner touches home plate.