Balk Justification

[Manny A]

Originally Posted by Rufus

Since this is a balk the ball is dead by 5.09(c), correct?

FWIW, in this particular situation, the ball is dead immediately since the pitcher balked but never delivered a pitch or throw.

But in reality, 5.09(c) as written is not entirely accurate, because not all balks in OBR result in a dead ball.

[Lapopez]

Originally Posted by Manny A

But in reality, 5.09(c) as written is not entirely accurate, because not all balks in OBR result in a dead ball.

5.09(c) references Penalty 8.05, where this is clearly stated.