What do you have?

[jicecone]

Pete, I am all for sticking to the OP.

"As the runner is trying to get by the catcher the runner holds up his left arm to me it looked liked to duck the tag or avoid getting hit by the ball."

That certainly leads me to believe he wasn't sure why is arm was raised.

Then this is followed up with another post,

"Also the only reason for the very short conference was to ask if he seen an elbow thrown".

Still sounds to me like he wasn't sure.

In your situation the PU clearly saw it better than you and didnt need your help. I agree, I wouldn't have asked for help either. But if he did clearly miss it and as a result you had to clean the mess up later because of what the def player perceived, then you might not have been as congenial to you partner as you were.

Your making the case for PU that CLEARLY sees what happened. I agree.

This OP is about one that didn't.

It may not look pretty afterwards, but there is nothing wrong in admitting you didn't see everything.