Infiled Fly, If Fair

[Tim C]

Ask yourself the following:

When does a ball become fair or foul?

You are thinking too much on this one.

The BALL was never a fair ball (i.e. it had not qualified under the rules that constitute a fair ball).

When you got back your senses (trust me I think we have all had some kind of a play do this to our "common sense") and called the ball foul and sent everyone back you did what was required.

The ball was foul. It can't be both foul and fair on the same play.