Did I see that Right?

[mbyron]

Originally Posted by Ump Rube

Call R1 out for passing preceding runner, let R2 go back to 1B, toss the coach during the sh!tstorm that ensues.

The passing did not take place during live-ball base-running. You don't get outs on this play, because the defense didn't put anyone out, and the offense didn't do anything that's penalized by declaring an out.

Penalize the infraction that occurred and the perpetrator(s) with the penalty specified in the rules.