wow

[David B]

Originally Posted by Kevin Finnerty

All of the Series umpiring has been just wonderful. I see nothing wrong at all with anything or anyone. In fact, I'm thinking of incorporating the Danley strike/appeal mechanic. They're the best umpires in the world, and they have shown it with each and every call, which so far have been 100% perfect. Like always.

Is that good?

Might want to take a look at espn.com. Umpires just admitted to missed calls in two games in a row. Even though, in real time, I think the call at third was correct.

It's easy to find a tag on a frame per frame shot, but in real time, if the glove doesn't move, then the umpire has to call it as he sees it.

thanks
David

[jimpiano]

Originally Posted by David B

Might want to take a look at espn.com. Umpires just admitted to missed calls in two games in a row. Even though, in real time, I think the call at third was correct.

It's easy to find a tag on a frame per frame shot, but in real time, if the glove doesn't move, then the umpire has to call it as he sees it.

thanks
David

Which, of course, exposes the trap of instant replay.