Does the run score?
FED, R3, 2 outs, 2 strikes on the batter. Pitcher in windup position not paying attention to R3. R3 takes off for home. Pitcher begins windup, but R3 has just a huge jump that he crosses home plate before the ball gets to the batter. The batter watches the pitch right down the middle of the strike zone for strike three.
Score it or not? |
TwoBits,
No, the run does not score. However, the R3 has a MAJOR contract in his future. JM |
As JM says, no score. Batter was 3rd out before reaching first base.
|
nice question...no run...see bossman72 and others
|
Quote:
I see 9.1.1 Situation G where the batter strikes before the runner crosses, but I don't know why the run doesn't count when the runner crossed before strike 3. Seems like the run should count to me. What am I missing? |
mick,
It goes to the definiton of "a play" as used in 4.09(b)Ex.(1): Quote:
In this context, the universal interpretation is that "a play" begins when the pitcher initiates his delivery. Since the BR did not reach 1B safely, and it was the 3rd out, and the runner occupied 3B when the play began, his run does not score. Likewise, if somehow the batter had hit a fly ball (without killing the R3) instead of striking out, and the ball were caught with less than 2 outs, the runner would be under a 7.10(a) retouch obligation. JM |
Quote:
From a 1995 J/R: It is a play if there is aI understand that MLB and Fed will vary, but a pitch being considered a play must be related only to Fed (if it really is) and not to levels above [MLB] or below [LL]. ;) |
Mick,
As I said above, the phrase "a play" has a number of different meanings. The J/R discussion you cite is in reference to appeals and baserunning awards as mentioned in 7.10 and 7.05(g). J/R uses the phrase "continuous action" (which you will find nowhere in the rule book) to define the "related action" or "play" during which a run is nullified if the BR does not reach 1B. JM |
Would not the time of the pitch be a factor to be considered here? If the batter had fouled off the pitch, R3 would return to 3rd because he did not reach the plate before the TOP. So in the OP, he did not score before the TOP and the batter was retired for the third out and logically, no run scores.
|
Quote:
Actually the J/R quote came from the definition *pairs* [Play or No Play]. I should have noted that. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
And in the OP the runner scored before the play, while in the case given, the runner crossed during the play. :) |
Quote:
|
I would also say that a pitch is a Throw from one fielder to another in an attempt to get someone out. But that may be streaching it a bit. :D
|
I am on the side of those who believe the run doesn't count. However, this is the problem that is being debated in my association:
FED Rule 9-1-1 Exception: A run is not scored if the runner advances to home plate during action in whcih the third out is made as follows: a) by the batter-runner before he touches first base. This is also OBR Rule 4.09a Exception 1. The "batter-runner" is defined in FED Rule 2-7-3: A batter-runner is a palyer who has finished a time at bat until he is put out or until playing action ends. Batter-runner is similarly defined in OBR Rule 2.00 In this situation, remember the pitch had not yet been ruled strike three until after R3 had crossed the plate. The debate we are having is that the batter had not finished his time at bat because the pitch had not yet crossed the plate and cannot considered a batter-runner. Therefore, rules referencing batter-runner do not apply here. |
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:11pm. |