question on "interference"

[mick]

Originally Posted by David Emerling

So, if R1 was advancing to 3rd at the time the ODB "interfered" with the play, you would put the runner back to 2nd?

I, too, would consider the lack of action on the ODB's part as an intentional act. In other words, he intentionally did not avoid a live ball.

One question: Are your required to place R1 at 2nd, or, are you exercising umpire's judgment on this?

Could you have ruled interference on the ODB and still awarded R1 3rd? Would that have been a legal option for the umpire?

David Emerling
Memphis, TN

Shucks, David,
You asked two questions !

I don't know what I am required to do, or what legal options are available.

But when ODB contacted the live avoidable ball, that ball is dead. If I look at the runner and he is between bases, I would have a hard time rationalizing a gift to the offenders. Send him back. If he hadn't made 2B, send him back to first.

If this isn't correct, I can change my mind.