Question on Awards with Tagging up

[Justme]

Originally Posted by PWL

Go up and read my earlier posts. I said two bases from time of throw from last legally obtained base. Runner has not legally obtained 2B without tagging up. Two base award from 1B, thus his award would be 3B. Runner must go back and re-tag 1B, touch 2B and 3B. If he does not do this defense is entitled to appeal, which must be done properly.

Just that simple.

Just for the sake of discussion let me ask these questions.

Since a missed base or failure to tag up is an appeal how could you justify awarding 3B and not home in this situation? Wouldn't your base award indicate that the runner didn't tag up? Especially since the offensive coach would probably ask you why his player didn't get 2 bases from 2B.

If the failure to tag up isn't appealed then it didn't happen right?