Yankees @ Angels - Game 5 ALDS

[David B]

Originally posted by DG
See Braves@Astros Game3 thread where there is discussion about the balk call, the announcers who were clueless, but not much about whether it was a correct call.

Contrast to this thread where there is a lot of discussion about whether correct or not, with what looks like a near split in opinion.

I vote for bad call on the balk (although it did not make any difference since it was ball 4) and good call on the running lane violation, and yes I know these are major league umpires... so don't bother to remind me.

Don't know who the other guys are but I think I made it quite clear that I watched the game, the replays, and the rest of the action and I thought it was a very good call.

Like it or not, F1 did balk and the umpire made the correct call by rule.

Must have missed my post.

Thanks
David