Please, make the MLB/NCAA call

[bob jenkins]

Originally posted by SAump

I still think the runner's safe,

Yes, the runner is safe, because that's how the umpire ruled.

But, the runner should have been out, because that's how Yeast reviewed the play.

I and others in this thread have explained why we agree with Yeast -- the runner went out of the established path by more than 3' to avoid a tag.

Why do you think the original umpire was correct?