Running Lane?

[DG]

I was a spectator for this one tonight, and sitting almost on the 1B line extended. R3 and R1, 2 out. Batter bunts up the first base line about 1 foot fair, right handed 1B comes in to field the ball, does so about 30 feet from the bag and swipes at the runner to attempt a tag. Runner was running in the center of the running lane, or maybe even slightly to the right side of the lane, and turned his body as the 1B swipes at him and clearly stepped out of the lane, but not far out. BU points to PU, who makes a safe call as 1B clearly missed the tag. After a lengthy discussion (calm one) with the defensive coach, the BU goes to the parking lot and comes back with a rulebook. Apparently defensive coach is appealing the decision based on a rule. After reviewing the book the umpires got both coaches to a meeting and ruling was made. Delay took about 10 minutes to resolve and it was all very calmly done. I know what I am thinking the whole time, but curious what the forum has to say. I know both the umpires, they are in my association, so I can't wait to discuss it with them.

This was a conference tournament semi-final, and the score was 0-0 at the time, and in the bottom of the 4th. I will tell what was ruled when I hear what the possibilities could have been, and in particular since the rulebook was consulted.

[Edited by DG on May 12th, 2005 at 12:34 AM]