Changing Calls

[ump24]

I am very concerned by some of the things I have been reading about as of late on this site. Several different people have posted the position ,"get the call right at all cost". I agree with this position, but only to a point.

In the case of the UT play, this is a call that can be reversed easily enough. Granted, Brandon Padgett didn't handle the play correctly, the rule book specifically gives the authority to all umpires to call a dead ball (HBP). My only point in saying this is that it MUST be done in a timely fashion. To allow an extended arguement to go on with out stepping in to immediately correct an error is poor.

This is not the same as changing an out to a safe or a safe to an out. I read a post that stated that AFTER making a call at first base that it was OK to be coerced into seeking help on whether a player pulled his foot. I emphatically say NO. The only way to get help on this play is to ask for help first. Not after you have already made a call.

When it is a situation that you have the sole responsibility of covering, you must make the call and stick with it. Going to a partner after an out or safe has been made is not acceptable. So, what is acceptable?
1)Check swings that have not been called a strike.
2)Fair balls to foul. NOT FOUL TO FAIR!
3)Asking for help on a tag BEFORE making a call.

There may be other instances but those are the only ones I have at present.

Again, the idea that you may go to a fellow official on any situation that he may have knowledge of is ludicrous. Be competent and take care of your business.