Cubs-Braves Bottom 6--what a mess.

[YoungRighty]

Everything seemed to make sense eventually by the explanation of the umpire supervisor (didn't catch who it was)...except that the throw to second appeared to have happened after Sheffield (BR) had passed Giles (R1). If that was in fact the case, shouldn't Sheffield have been called out and Giles allowed to return to first (although I'm not sure he ever made it back all the way)?

Giles appeared to me to be claiming that one of the umpires (RF?) was signalling "catch"...and one of the announcers mentioned that early in the sorting out process. But then I never heard any more about that part of it. I don't think any of the cameras caught the umpires, as I couldn't see any of them in the replays until the out call at 2B.