legal tag?

[nine01c]

SC: The play as described is not being questioned because of the umpire's "judgment." I mean, it's not like a banger at 1st or a possible pulled foot that the coach comes out and argues the decision (judgment). This play is being questioned because of (umpire's) failure to apply a "rule."
The rule being that on a force (fly ball not caught) the runner must reach his advance base before the fielder secures the ball (and touches base or runner). This runner clearly did not beat the throw as EVERYONE knows. Imagine this is an elimination play-off game, bottom of the 7th, tie game, winner goes to state championship tourney, loser goes home. Hmmm...

When you misapply or fail to apply a "rule" it CAN be corrected, and rightly so (obviously before the next pitch). An umpire who admits a mistake (even such an embarassing one) and applies the rule correctly will gain respect. Insisting on sticking with your (incorrect ruling) will harm your credibility. IMO