My breakdown of this:
The BR overran the base but did not touch it; he returned and touched before he was tagged, (the tag would be an appeal anyway, so even if the tag was before the touch, there would have to be someting indicating an appeal).
But, then the BR lost contact with the base after returning, so on the second tag, out.
I get the point about any ol' direction on the overrun, but this is close enough to be an overrun (the first time) IMO. Besides, technically, the BR loses his protection for an try for 2nd, not for a somewhat curved overrun path.
But, in the end the BR is out on the second tag.
__________________
Tom
|