Quote:
Originally Posted by deecee
After 15 years I think I know what a fumble is. In this instance with what was described I would not call this a fumble. Changing your mind on a pass and deciding to try and hold on the ball but the ball still pops out is a pass, albeit crappy one, in my book. I'm not rewarding bad offense or penalizing good defense here.
|
You are not answering the OP.
In the OP, it was judged (however crappily) to be a fumble. You are saying that it should almost never be judged to be so.
Thus, the disconnect in the thread.
You're both right.