Quote:
Originally Posted by JRutledge
At least where I live, the LJ is supposed to count defense. The Umpire and Referee are the main people counting offense. So if you have fewer than 11, the wing does not have to complicate this by worrying about how many are in the backfield compared to how many are actually on the field.
|
You have this completely flipped.
It is faster to count backs than it is number of linemen.
If the rule requires no more than 4 in the backfield, it doesn't matter how many players the offense has.
As it stands now, in Fed, if you want to count backs to determine legality, you need to pick up the count from the R or U. Otherwise you need to count the linemen which isn't all that easy sometimes.
Not to mention the fact that if the offense is lined up with a missing lineman, it's going to be a foul and it's a dumb one. Not a problem in NCAA.
Having called high school under both rules, I'd much rather have the NCAA rule. It would be a simple and pain free change to make.