Jeff,
Two things...
First, R1 does not morph into being a coach. R1 is a retired runner.
Second, speaking ASA, your statement,
Quote:
|
Any contact made between the coach and the runner - runner is out. "Intent" is not an option.
|
is incorrect. "Contact" is not what is illegal. "Assistance" is. The rule reads as follows:
Quote:
|
ASA 8-7E The runner is out when anyone other than another runner physically assists the runner while the ball is in play
|
"anyone other than another runner" includes a retired runner. It does not have to be a coach. "Physially assists" can be things like grabbing the runner to hold them on base, pushing the runner to get them moving, grabbing the runner's hand to pull him to his feet, etc. Getting in the way of a runner gunning for home is unlikely to be considered "assisting."