Quote:
Originally Posted by so cal lurker
Me thinks that many of the responses you get are going to depend upon the picture the reader builds from the words. It seems to me (not a ref) that the details on the contact are going to matter a lot here on how they tangled. If the blocker was going up and over such that there was no way to block the shot without subsequently wiping out the shooter, I think that is pretty easily a foul. If there is minor contact from two players who fall because they are running at speed that seems to me not a foul. And there is a whole lot of grey in between those.
|
Agreed.
I'm in the camp that is more likely to pass on a foul that involves a clean block up top with some contact below but this is a HTBT situation.
I will say though that the fact the play from the defender "from behind" makes it more likely that I have a foul on this play.
But again tough to say with out seeing the specific play in question.
ETA- And as others have suggested, the level of play is also a significant factor here. With bigger and more athletic players you are going to see, and assigners and coaches expect, more contact to be deemed marginal or incidental.