Quote:
Originally posted by BktBallRef
we just need a picture of Chuck, since he's been speechless since I challenged him on this.
|
Sorry. I had to drive my parents to the airport this morning. See? Sometimes I actually do have a life.
Anyway, here's my "contribution". Let's change the scenario slightly. A1 begins his try. B1 bats the ball out of A1's hands before A1 releases the try. (So far, it's the same.) But suppose that instead of directing the ball toward the backcourt, B1's bat sends the ball toward A's goal. The ball is in flight. The horn sounds, ending the period. The ball enters the basket. You gonna count it?
If you say that the basket is good, then you think that A1 released a try for goal, meaning that team control ended. In that case, you also have to say that there would be no backcourt violation in the original play.
If you wave off the basket, then you obviously think that A1 did not release a try for goal. In that case, you also have to say that you would call the backcourt violation.
Personally, I'm leaning to waving off the basket.