Quote:
Originally Posted by Manny A
I'm sorry, but I just don't have the clairvoyance to determine what the runner might have achieved minus the obstruction without letting everything play out.
|
Then you are probably in the wrong job since a good portion of an umpire's responsibilities involves making decisions based upon conjecture
Quote:
|
Where does it say in the rules and interpretations that we must decide immediately what the proper award should be, and not deviate from that decision, no matter what happens next?
|
Where does it say you shouldn't? If you had attended a national clinic or school, or even just the CAR clinic, or at least when it was a decent rules clinic, you probably would have heard that direction.
And it is nothing new. Same direction I received a quarter of a century ago long before I became a UIC and clinician.